Question

Петя, Вася и Коля играли с мячом, и кто из них разбил стекло? На вопрос кто это сделал, двое свидетелей ответили "Петя или Вася", пятеро - "Вася или Коля", трое "Коля или Петя", а остальные четверо сказали, что не знают. Потом выяснилось, что правду сказали ровно шестеро свидетелей. Кто разбил стекло?

Answer 1

Мне кажется что коля разбиил окно

Answer 2

Analysis of the Situation

Three individuals, Petya, Vasya, and Kolya, were playing with a ball, and the task is to determine who broke the window. The witnesses' statements are as follows: - Two witnesses said it was either Petya or Vasya. - Five witnesses said it was either Vasya or Kolya. - Three witnesses said it was either Kolya or Petya. - Four witnesses claimed they did not know who did it.

Deduction from Witness Statements

From the given information, it is clear that the statements of six witnesses were true. Let's analyze the possibilities based on the witness statements and the truthfulness of the statements.

Possible Scenarios

1. If Petya broke the window: - Two witnesses who said it was either Petya or Vasya are telling the truth. - Three witnesses who said it was either Kolya or Petya are lying. - Four witnesses who claimed they did not know are lying.

2. If Vasya broke the window: - Two witnesses who said it was either Petya or Vasya are telling the truth. - Five witnesses who said it was either Vasya or Kolya are telling the truth. - Four witnesses who claimed they did not know are lying.

3. If Kolya broke the window: - Five witnesses who said it was either Vasya or Kolya are telling the truth. - Three witnesses who said it was either Kolya or Petya are telling the truth. - Four witnesses who claimed they did not know are lying.

Conclusion

Based on the analysis, it can be concluded that Vasya broke the window. This conclusion is drawn from the fact that the statements of six witnesses were true, and in the scenario where Vasya broke the window, all the witness statements align with the truth.

This deduction is based on the information provided and the logic applied to analyze the given scenario.