Question

Вкажіть, хто з вказаних осіб вчинив згідно з цивільним правом, а хто - ні? А.14-річний Іван з дозволу батьків купив у сусіда книгу; Б. 19-річна Марина приїхала в інше місто і найняла квартиру; В. 13-річна Наталка подарувала за власним бажанням своїй подрузі блузку; Г. 17-річний Сергій без відома батьків уклав договір позики з метою купівлі магнітофона; Ґ. 16-річний Олег придбав без відома батьків мотоцикл.​

Answer 1

А і б) з цивільним правом все інше ні

Answer 2

Who acted in accordance with civil law and who did not?

According to civil law, the ability to engage in certain legal actions can vary depending on the age of the individual. Let's analyze each scenario to determine whether the actions were in accordance with civil law or not:

A. 14-year-old Ivan bought a book from his neighbor with the permission of his parents. - In this case, Ivan acted in accordance with civil law. In many jurisdictions, minors can engage in certain legal transactions with the consent of their parents or legal guardians [[1]].

B. 19-year-old Marina rented an apartment in another city. - Marina acted in accordance with civil law. At the age of 19, she is considered an adult in most jurisdictions and has the legal capacity to enter into contracts, including renting an apartment [[2]].

C. 13-year-old Natalia voluntarily gave her blouse as a gift to her friend. - Natalia's action of giving her blouse as a gift is generally considered to be in accordance with civil law. Minors can make gifts without the need for parental consent in many jurisdictions [[3]].

D. 17-year-old Sergey entered into a loan agreement without his parents' knowledge in order to buy a tape recorder. - Sergey's action of entering into a loan agreement without his parents' knowledge is generally not in accordance with civil law. Minors usually lack the legal capacity to enter into binding contracts without the consent of their parents or legal guardians [[4]].

E. 16-year-old Oleg purchased a motorcycle without his parents' knowledge. - Oleg's action of purchasing a motorcycle without his parents' knowledge is generally not in accordance with civil law. Minors usually lack the legal capacity to enter into binding contracts without the consent of their parents or legal guardians [[4]].

In summary, the individuals who acted in accordance with civil law are Ivan (A), Marina (B), and Natalia (C). Sergey (D) and Oleg (E) did not act in accordance with civil law as they engaged in legal actions without the necessary consent or legal capacity.

Please note that the specific laws regarding the legal capacity of minors may vary depending on the jurisdiction. It is always advisable to consult the relevant civil laws in your specific jurisdiction for accurate information.

Let me know if there's anything else I can help you with!