Question

Бабушка Аграфена пригласила своих любимых внучек – Машу, Дашу, Наташу, Василису – на чай со вкусными конфетами. Заглянув в ящик со сладостями, бабушка удивилась – кто-то из внучек съел все конфеты! Бабушка спросила у каждой внучки, кто съел конфеты. Маша сказала, что не знает. Даша сказала, что это была Маша, и что Василиса никогда-никогда не обманывает. Наташа сказала, что это была либо Даша, либо Маша. Василиса сказала, что все остальные внучки соврали. Мудрая бабушка Аграфена поняла, что как минимум две внучки говорят правду, но забыла, кто именно. Кто из внучек говорит правду? Маша Даша Наташа Василиса Кто из внучек съел конфеты?Маша Даша Наташа Василиса

Answer 1

Ответ:

Объяснение:правду говорят Маша и Наташа,а съела Даша.это точно и верно

Answer 2

Ответ:

1) Маша.........

2) Маша.......

Answer 3

Solution:

To solve this riddle, we can analyze the statements of each granddaughter and determine who is telling the truth and who is lying.

- Masha: Claims she doesn't know who ate the candies. - Dasha: Accuses Masha and claims Vasilisa never lies. - Natasha: Accuses either Dasha or Masha. - Vasilisa: Accuses all the other granddaughters of lying.

From the statements, we can deduce the following: 1. If Masha is telling the truth, then Dasha is lying, which means Natasha is also lying. This would make Vasilisa's statement true, but that would contradict Masha's statement. 2. If Dasha is telling the truth, then Masha is lying, which means Natasha is telling the truth. This would make Vasilisa's statement false, which contradicts Dasha's claim that Vasilisa never lies. 3. If Natasha is telling the truth, then Dasha is lying, which means Masha is also lying. This would make Vasilisa's statement false, which contradicts Dasha's claim that Vasilisa never lies. 4. If Vasilisa is telling the truth, then all the other granddaughters are lying, which contradicts the fact that at least two granddaughters are telling the truth.

Therefore, we have a contradiction in each scenario, which means there is no consistent solution to this riddle. It's a classic logic puzzle known as the "liar paradox" or "liar's paradox," where the statements lead to a logical contradiction.

So, it's not possible to determine who is telling the truth or who ate the candies based on the given information.

Conclusion:

The riddle presents a classic logical paradox where the statements of the granddaughters lead to a contradiction, making it impossible to determine who is telling the truth or who ate the candies.