Question

Гусейнов продал Костюкову принадлежащее ему на праве личной собственности охотничье ружье. Узнав о состоявшемся договоре купли продажи, районное отделение милиции потребовало от Костюкова возвращения ружья Гусейнову, а от последнего - возвращения полученных денег покупателю. Свое требование районное отделение милиции обосновало наличием правил, в силу которых приобретение охотничьих ружей возможно лишь при наличии у покупателя документа о членстве в добровольном обществе охотников. Какие объекты могут находиться в личной собственности гражданина? В праве ли гражданин продать принадлежащее ему имущество по своему усмотрению? Правомерно ли требование районного отделения милиции?

Answer 1

Нельзя продать и купить оружию без документации.По моему милиция поступил правильно

Answer 2

Objects in Personal Ownership

In accordance with Russian civil law, citizens have the right to own various objects as personal property. These objects can include real estate, vehicles, household items, and other possessions that are legally acquired and registered in the individual's name. Personal property is defined as property that is not designated for public use and is owned by an individual or individuals.

Right to Sell Personal Property

Under Russian law, citizens generally have the right to sell their personal property at their discretion. This includes the right to sell items such as hunting rifles that are legally owned by the individual. However, certain regulations and requirements may apply to the sale of specific types of property, such as hunting rifles, which may be subject to additional licensing or documentation requirements.

Legitimacy of the Police Department's Demand

The legitimacy of the demand made by the local police department for the return of the rifle and the reimbursement of the purchase price depends on the specific legal requirements and regulations governing the sale and ownership of hunting rifles in the relevant jurisdiction. The police department cited the requirement for the buyer to have a document proving membership in a voluntary hunting society as a basis for their demand. Whether this requirement is a valid legal basis for the demand would depend on the specific laws and regulations governing the sale and ownership of hunting rifles in the area.

It's important to note that the legality of the police department's demand and the actions of the individuals involved would need to be assessed in accordance with the specific legal framework and regulations applicable to the sale and ownership of hunting rifles in the given jurisdiction.