Question

К сотрудникам полиции обратилась гражданка с сообщением о том, что ранее судимый сосед собирает у себя дома несовершеннолетних, распивает с ними спиртные напитки, на лестничной площадке постоянно мусор, окурки от сигарет, стены исписаны. Компании ведут себя шумно, нарушают ночной покой и отдых граждан, проживающих в доме. Дайте правовую оценку действиям несовершеннолетних и соседа. Какие действия должны совершить сотрудники полиции?

Answer 1

так как этот человек беспокоит всех ночью и не даёт покоя его должны арестовать за то что он не знает свои права и как жить он нарушает закон и не даёт людям спать

Answer 2

Reporting a Complaint to the Police

A citizen has approached the police with a complaint about their neighbor, who is a previously convicted individual. The complainant alleges that the neighbor is hosting underage individuals at their home, consuming alcoholic beverages with them, and causing disturbances in the building. The complainant also mentions the presence of litter, cigarette butts, and graffiti on the stairwell. The police are seeking a legal assessment of the actions of the underage individuals and the neighbor, as well as guidance on the appropriate actions to be taken by the police.

Legal Assessment of the Actions

1. Actions of the Underage Individuals: The consumption of alcoholic beverages by underage individuals is generally considered illegal in many jurisdictions. The specific laws and regulations regarding underage drinking may vary depending on the country and local legislation. In most cases, it is illegal for individuals under a certain age to consume alcohol, and those who provide alcohol to minors may also be held liable for their actions. The police should investigate the allegations and gather evidence to determine if any laws have been violated.

2. Actions of the Neighbor: The neighbor's behavior, such as hosting underage individuals and consuming alcohol with them, may be considered inappropriate or potentially illegal, depending on the specific circumstances and local laws. Additionally, the presence of litter, cigarette butts, and graffiti may be considered a violation of public order or property damage laws. The police should assess the situation and gather evidence to determine if any laws have been breached.

Actions to be Taken by the Police

1. Investigation: The police should conduct a thorough investigation into the allegations made by the complainant. This may involve interviewing the complainant, gathering witness statements, and collecting any available evidence, such as photographs or videos of the alleged activities. The police should also consider the credibility of the complainant and any potential motives for making false accusations.

2. Legal Intervention: If the investigation reveals evidence of illegal activities, the police may take appropriate legal action. This could involve arresting and charging the neighbor if they are found to be in violation of any laws, such as providing alcohol to minors or engaging in disorderly conduct. The underage individuals involved may also face legal consequences, depending on the specific laws regarding underage drinking in the jurisdiction.

3. Community Engagement: In addition to legal intervention, the police should also consider engaging with the community to address the ongoing disturbances and maintain public order. This may involve working with local residents, community organizations, or building management to address the issues raised by the complainant. The police can provide guidance on how to report disturbances, encourage residents to document incidents, and offer advice on conflict resolution.

4. Referral to Other Agencies: Depending on the specific circumstances and jurisdiction, the police may need to involve other relevant agencies or organizations. For example, if the underage individuals are at risk or in need of support, the police may need to involve child protective services or social services. Similarly, if the neighbor's actions are in violation of specific housing regulations, the police may need to involve local housing authorities.

It is important to note that the specific actions taken by the police will depend on the laws and regulations of the jurisdiction in question. The police should follow established protocols and procedures while conducting their investigation and taking appropriate legal action.