Question

Решите задачу: Гришин, находясь в состоянии алкогольного опьянения, упал и сломал руку. В приёмном отделении он отказался пройти рентгенологическое обследование, а просил поставить ему обезболивающий укол и отпустит. Могут ли работники медицинских организаций заставить пациента проходить необходимые медицинские процедуры? Может ли медицинская помощь отказываться в принудительном порядке?

Answer 1

Ответ:

Если он написал отказ ,то врачи не имеют права его заставлять

Answer 2

Can medical workers force a patient to undergo necessary medical procedures?

In general, medical workers cannot force a patient to undergo necessary medical procedures against their will. However, there are certain situations where medical professionals may have the authority to provide medical treatment without the patient's consent. This is typically done in cases where the patient's life is in immediate danger and they are unable to provide informed consent.

In the case of Grishin, who is in a state of alcohol intoxication and refuses to undergo an X-ray examination, medical workers may not be able to force him to undergo the procedure. However, they have a duty to provide appropriate medical care and ensure the patient's well-being. This may involve explaining the importance of the procedure and the potential risks of not undergoing it. Ultimately, the decision to undergo the procedure lies with the patient, unless there are exceptional circumstances that warrant overriding their refusal.

It's important to note that laws and regulations regarding medical consent may vary between countries and jurisdictions. It is always best to consult local laws and seek legal advice if necessary.