Question

А.П. Чехов "Толстый и тонкий" В первой редакции рассказа "тонкий" унижался, так как "толстый" оказывался его прямым начальником и распекал за опоздание на службу. Затем Чехов переработал рассказ. Теперь "толстый" изображен нейтрально, главным объектом осмеяния стал маленький чиновник, который подличает и пресмыкается, когда его к этому никто не принуждает. Как вы думаете, в чем смысл этого изменения? ПОЖАЛУЙСТА!!!!!!!

Answer 1

Я считаю, что не каждый богатый, то есть как в этом произведении "Толстый" лицемер. Есть люди, я которые поболтать с тобой по душам

Answer 2

Changes in "The Fat and the Thin" by Anton Chekhov

In the first version of the story "The Fat and the Thin" by Anton Chekhov, the character "Thin" is depicted as being humiliated by the character "Fat." "Thin" is shown to be subordinate to "Fat" and is reprimanded for being late to work. However, Chekhov later revised the story, and in the final version, the character "Fat" is portrayed neutrally. The main target of ridicule becomes a small official who grovels and flatters others even when not compelled to do so.

The Meaning of this Change

The change in the portrayal of the characters in "The Fat and the Thin" reflects a shift in Chekhov's focus and message. In the revised version, the emphasis is no longer on the power dynamics between "Fat" and "Thin," but rather on the behavior of the small official who willingly debases himself without any external pressure to do so.

By shifting the focus to the small official, Chekhov may be highlighting the theme of human nature and the tendency of some individuals to willingly submit to others, even when not explicitly forced to do so. This change allows Chekhov to explore the complexities of human behavior and the dynamics of power and subservience in a more nuanced way.

It is important to note that the exact intentions and interpretations of Chekhov's changes may vary, and different readers may have different perspectives on the meaning behind the revisions. The author's artistic choices often leave room for interpretation and multiple layers of meaning.

Overall, the change in the portrayal of the characters in "The Fat and the Thin" from the first version to the final version allows Chekhov to explore different aspects of human behavior and power dynamics, ultimately adding depth and complexity to the story.

I hope this helps! Let me know if you have any further questions.