Question

ВЫБРАТЬ ВАРИАНТЫ ОТВЕТА)Какие противоречат духу правового государства: 1.Интересы гос-ва выше интересов личности; 2.Суд должен быть независим от законодательной и исполнительной власти; 3.Реализация прав человека зависит от конкретной политической ситуации.

Answer 1

1,3 противоречат духу правового государства

Answer 2

Contradictions to the Spirit of a Legal State

In considering the statements provided and their alignment with the spirit of a legal state, it's important to evaluate each one in turn.

1. Interests of the state supersede individual interests - This statement contradicts the spirit of a legal state. A legal state typically upholds the primacy of individual rights and freedoms over the interests of the state. This principle is fundamental to the concept of the rule of law.

2. Independence of the judiciary from the legislative and executive branches - This statement aligns with the spirit of a legal state. The independence of the judiciary is a key characteristic of a legal state, ensuring that the judiciary can act as a check on the powers of the other branches of government.

3. Realization of human rights depends on the specific political situation - This statement contradicts the spirit of a legal state. In a legal state, the realization of human rights should not be contingent upon the political situation. Instead, human rights should be protected and upheld regardless of the prevailing political circumstances.

In summary, statement 1 contradicts the spirit of a legal state, while statements 2 and 3 align with and contradict the spirit of a legal state, respectively.

It's important to note that the principles of a legal state are fundamental to the protection of individual rights and the functioning of a just and fair society.

If you have further questions or need additional clarification on this topic, feel free to ask!