Question

Сравните финалы отношений Лизы и Алексея из рассказа Барышня крестьянка с помолвкой Маши Троекуровой и князя Верейского из романа Дубровский Помогите пожалуйста

Answer 1

Финалы отношений героев из пушкинских произведений разные.
В конце повести "Барышня-крестьянка" Алексей Берестов приезжает в имение Муромского, чтобы объяснить свое нежелание жениться на Лизавете Григорьевне, так как он любит другую. Но когда узнает в Лизе свою Акулину, ничего уже не мешает нашим героям быть вместе.
В романе "Дубровский" Маша Троекурова вынуждена выйти замуж за старого, нелюбимого князя Верейского. Владимир Дубровский не успевает спасти девушку до её венчания, после которого она уже и сама не сможет воспользоваться помощью Владимира, так как брак, освещенный в церкви, являлся нерушимым.

Answer 2

Comparing the Endings of the Relationships in "Baryshnya Krestyanka" and "Dubrovsky"

In the story "Baryshnya Krestyanka" by Alexander Pushkin and the novel "Dubrovsky" by Alexander Pushkin, the endings of the relationships between the characters differ significantly. Let's compare the endings of Lisa and Alexey's relationship in "Baryshnya Krestyanka" with the engagement of Masha Troekurova and Prince Vereisky in "Dubrovsky."

"Baryshnya Krestyanka" by Alexander Pushkin: In "Baryshnya Krestyanka," the relationship between Lisa and Alexey ends on a tragic note. Lisa, a young peasant girl, falls in love with Alexey, a nobleman. However, their relationship faces numerous obstacles due to their different social statuses. Despite their love for each other, they are unable to overcome these societal barriers.

The story concludes with Lisa's realization that their love is impossible, and she decides to sacrifice her own happiness for the sake of Alexey's future. She chooses to marry a wealthy merchant, Ivan Ivanovich, who can provide her with a comfortable life. This decision marks the end of Lisa and Alexey's relationship, as they part ways and go on to lead separate lives.

"Dubrovsky" by Alexander Pushkin: In "Dubrovsky," the engagement of Masha Troekurova and Prince Vereisky also faces challenges, but the outcome is more positive compared to "Baryshnya Krestyanka." Masha, a young noblewoman, is engaged to Prince Vereisky, a wealthy and influential man. However, their engagement is not based on love but rather on societal expectations and the desire for social advancement.

As the story progresses, Masha meets Dubrovsky, a nobleman who fights against injustice. She falls in love with him, and their relationship becomes a source of conflict and tension. Eventually, Masha breaks off her engagement with Prince Vereisky and chooses to be with Dubrovsky, despite the risks and challenges they may face.

The novel ends with Masha and Dubrovsky's decision to start a new life together, leaving behind their previous social positions and embracing their love for each other. Although their relationship may still face difficulties, their choice to be together represents a more hopeful and romantic ending compared to the tragic conclusion of Lisa and Alexey's relationship in "Baryshnya Krestyanka."

Conclusion:

In conclusion, the endings of the relationships in "Baryshnya Krestyanka" and "Dubrovsky" differ significantly. While Lisa and Alexey's relationship in "Baryshnya Krestyanka" ends tragically with their separation, Masha Troekurova and Prince Vereisky's engagement in "Dubrovsky" is broken off, and Masha chooses to be with Dubrovsky, leading to a more hopeful and romantic ending. These different outcomes reflect the themes of societal barriers, sacrifice, and the power of love in the works of Alexander Pushkin.