Question

Почему дед разбил телевизор? рассказ "Критики" Шукшин развёрнуто пожалуйста!​

Answer 1

однажды он поспорил с родственниками невестки, городской парой, приехавшей в деревню в гости. По телевизору показывали фильм и деду не понравился актёр, игравший плотника. Он с возмущением заявил, что актёр неправильно держит топор и так никто не делает. Гости возразили, что не важно, как актёр держит топор, важно, что человек чувствует, как передаёт эмоции своего героя. При этом они улыбались, понимая, что Тимофей Макарович хоть и любитель кино, но совершенно не разбирается в этом искусстве. Эти возражения страшно разозлили деда, потому что сам он плотник и построил полдеревни, так что знает, как топор в руках держать, не то, что эти городские. А улыбчивость гостей он посчитал насмешкой и даже оскорблением со стороны невежд, не знающих жизни.

И так это огорчило Тимофея Макаровича, что он напился и разбил телевизор.

Answer 2

Why did the grandfather break the television? A detailed analysis of Shukshin's story "Critics"

In the story "Critics" by Vasily Shukshin, the grandfather breaks the television for a specific reason. Let's delve into the details of the story to understand why this incident occurs.

The story "Critics" revolves around the theme of the clash between traditional rural values and the influence of modern technology, specifically television. The main character, the grandfather, represents the older generation rooted in traditional values, while the television symbolizes the intrusion of modernity into their lives.

The story begins with the arrival of a television in the village. The villagers, including the grandfather, gather around to watch it. However, the television quickly becomes a source of conflict and tension within the community. The villagers become obsessed with the television, neglecting their work and relationships. They start imitating the behavior and lifestyle portrayed on the screen, leading to a decline in their traditional values.

The grandfather, being a staunch defender of traditional values, becomes increasingly frustrated with the negative impact of the television on the village. He sees how it is corrupting the minds of the younger generation and eroding the values that he holds dear. This frustration eventually reaches a boiling point, leading him to take drastic action and break the television.

The act of breaking the television can be seen as a symbolic gesture of resistance against the encroachment of modernity and the erosion of traditional values. The grandfather's action is driven by his deep-rooted belief that the television is a destructive force that is tearing apart the fabric of their community.

It is important to note that the story "Critics" is a work of fiction by Vasily Shukshin, and the interpretation of the grandfather's actions may vary depending on the reader. However, the analysis provided here offers a plausible understanding of the motivations behind the grandfather's decision to break the television.

Note: The analysis provided above is based on the information available about the story "Critics" by Vasily Shukshin. The specific details and interpretations may vary depending on the reader's perspective.