Question

Была ли необходимость выплаты дани другим государствам

Answer 1

Выплата дани потерпевшим поражение государством обеспечивало победившей стране доход, пополнение казны и даже рабов и бесплатные рабочие силы

Answer 2

The Necessity of Paying Tribute to Other States

The necessity of paying tribute to other states has been a historical practice in various contexts. Tributes were often paid by weaker states to more powerful ones as a form of acknowledgment, submission, or protection. The reasons for paying tribute varied depending on the specific circumstances and historical period.

In ancient times, tribute payments were common among empires and city-states. These payments were often made by conquered or subordinate territories to the ruling power. The purpose of tribute in these cases was to maintain peace, secure protection, or gain favor with the dominant power. Failure to pay tribute could result in military intervention, economic sanctions, or other forms of punishment.

During the medieval period, feudal systems emerged in Europe, where vassals paid tribute to their lords in exchange for land, protection, and other privileges. This system was based on a hierarchical relationship between the lord and the vassal, with the vassal providing military service and other forms of support to the lord in return for the lord's protection and support.

In the context of international relations, tribute payments were sometimes made by weaker states to more powerful ones as a means of avoiding conflict or securing favorable trade agreements. These payments were often seen as a form of diplomacy or appeasement, aimed at maintaining peaceful relations and avoiding military confrontation.

It is important to note that the necessity of paying tribute to other states has evolved over time, and the specific reasons for tribute payments varied across different historical periods and regions. The practice of paying tribute has become less common in modern times, as the international system has shifted towards more formalized diplomatic relations, international law, and economic cooperation.

In conclusion, the necessity of paying tribute to other states has been a historical practice in various contexts, serving purposes such as maintaining peace, securing protection, gaining favor, or avoiding conflict. However, the specific reasons for tribute payments varied across different historical periods and regions.