Question

7. Что, по вашему мнению, дало основание Пушкину для следующего суждения: «Не приведи Господи увидеть русский бунт, бессмысленный и беспощадный». Почему бунт представлялся Пушкину бессмысленным? Беспощадным?

Answer 1

Возможно в то время было бессмысленно устраивать бунт против правителей и было без полезно доказывать свои какие либо интересы, а почему беспощадный, возможно убивали тех кто устраивал различные бунты и кто принемал в них участие

Answer 2

Pushkin's View on the Russian Uprising

Alexander Pushkin's statement, "Не приведи Господи увидеть русский бунт, бессмысленный и беспощадный" (Lord, spare me from witnessing a Russian uprising, senseless and merciless), reflects his perspective on the nature of a potential Russian uprising. Pushkin's view on the uprising being senseless and merciless can be attributed to several factors.

Senseless Uprising: Pushkin's characterization of the potential Russian uprising as "senseless" may stem from his perception of the potential consequences and outcomes of such an event. The historical context of social unrest and uprisings in Russia during Pushkin's time may have influenced his view on the futility or lack of purpose in such actions.

According to the social and political climate in 19th-century Russia was marked by significant tensions and discontent among various segments of society, which could have contributed to Pushkin's apprehension about the potential for a senseless uprising.

Merciless Nature: The descriptor "merciless" in Pushkin's statement suggests his belief in the potential for extreme brutality and violence in the event of an uprising. This perception may have been influenced by historical instances of harsh suppression of uprisings and the violent nature of social and political conflicts during Pushkin's era.

As noted in the XIX century in Russia was characterized by significant social and political upheaval, which could have shaped Pushkin's view of the potential uprising as being merciless.

In conclusion, Pushkin's statement reflects his apprehension about the potential consequences of a Russian uprising, viewing it as senseless and merciless due to the historical context of social unrest and the perceived outcomes of such events during his time.