Question

Если бы вы оказались на месте Наполеона Бонапарта в 1814 г. рискнули бы совершить побег с о. Эльба, ради того чтобы вернуть себе былую власть и славу, зная что через 100 дней потеряете ее навсегда?

Answer 1

Да,если бы был Наполеоном ,он ведь страдал на этом острове говорил ,что император умер( о себе),что он ничто,пытался успокоить себя ," Наполеон везде счастлив",но мы -то понимаем ,что для него это было мучительно.Странно было бы разрушителю старых норм и созданию новых лежать без дела и думать только о семье и о "делах" в пределах этого острова 

Answer 2

Risk of Escape from Elba in 1814

If I were in Napoleon Bonaparte's position in 1814, the decision to risk an escape from Elba to regain former power and glory, knowing that it would ultimately lead to a permanent loss within 100 days, would be a complex and weighty one. The potential consequences and the historical context surrounding Napoleon's situation would need to be carefully considered.

Historical Context: Napoleon Bonaparte's exile to the island of Elba in 1814 followed his abdication as Emperor of the French and the signing of the Treaty of Fontainebleau. This treaty granted him sovereignty over the island of Elba and allowed him to retain the title of Emperor. However, his exile was not a complete removal from the political landscape, and he maintained a degree of influence and authority over the island.

Risks and Consequences: The decision to escape from Elba and attempt to regain power in France would carry significant risks. It would involve defying the terms of the Treaty of Fontainebleau and challenging the restored Bourbon monarchy in France. The potential consequences of a failed attempt at restoration could be dire, including further exile or even imprisonment.

Temporary Restoration and Ultimate Defeat: Napoleon's return from Elba in 1815, known as the Hundred Days, did result in a brief restoration of power. However, his defeat at the Battle of Waterloo led to his second abdication and subsequent exile to the remote island of Saint Helena, where he would spend the remainder of his life.

Considerations: In considering whether to risk the escape from Elba, it would be essential to weigh the potential short-term gains against the long-term consequences. The likelihood of success, the support he could rally, and the potential impact on the stability of the region would all need to be carefully evaluated.

Conclusion: Ultimately, the decision to risk an escape from Elba in 1814 would have been a momentous and fateful one for Napoleon Bonaparte. The complex interplay of historical circumstances, personal ambition, and the pursuit of power would have made this a decision of immense significance, with far-reaching implications for both Napoleon and the course of European history.