Question

LOOK OUT! When a single event interrupts a longer event, we can use either while/as with the past continuous, or when with the past simple. While / As I was walking along the beach, I found a gold coin. I was walking along the beach when I found a gold coin. 10 сойлем жазу ​

Answer 1

Ответ:

You are absolutely correct! Both "while/as with the past continuous" and "when with the past simple" can be used when a single event interrupts a longer event in the past. Your examples demonstrate this perfectly:

You are absolutely correct! Both "while/as with the past continuous" and "when with the past simple" can be used when a single event interrupts a longer event in the past. Your examples demonstrate this perfectly:1. "While/As I was walking along the beach, I found a gold coin."

You are absolutely correct! Both "while/as with the past continuous" and "when with the past simple" can be used when a single event interrupts a longer event in the past. Your examples demonstrate this perfectly:1. "While/As I was walking along the beach, I found a gold coin."2. "I was walking along the beach when I found a gold coin."

You are absolutely correct! Both "while/as with the past continuous" and "when with the past simple" can be used when a single event interrupts a longer event in the past. Your examples demonstrate this perfectly:1. "While/As I was walking along the beach, I found a gold coin."2. "I was walking along the beach when I found a gold coin."Both sentences convey the same idea that the action of finding a gold coin interrupted the ongoing action of walking along the beach in the past. It's a matter of personal preference which one to use; they are both grammatically correct.

Можно лучший ответ?

Answer 2

Оба предложения, "While/as I was walking along the beach, I found a gold coin" и "I was walking along the beach when I found a gold coin", корректны и имеют схожий смысл. Оба используют комбинацию прошедшего продолжительного времени (past continuous) и прошедшего простого времени (past simple) для описания события, которое было прервано другим событием.

Сначала используется прошедшее продолжительное время (past continuous) "I was walking along the beach", чтобы указать на длительное действие, которое уже происходило. Затем, вводится прошедшее простое время (past simple) "I found a gold coin", чтобы упомянуть о событии, которое прервало длительное действие.

В целом, оба предложения передают идею, что длительное действие (прогулка по пляжу) было прервано находкой золотой монеты. Использование "while/as" или "when" в этих предложениях предоставляет возможность упорядочить последовательность событий.

Надеюсь, это помогло! Если у вас есть еще вопросы, не стесняйтесь задавать.