Question

. Доведіть, що твір Панаса Мирного «Хіба ревуть воли, як ясла повні?» є реалістичним. Відповідь аргументуйте.​

Answer 1

В основі роману написаного Панасом Мирним та Іваном Біликом "хіба ревуть воли,як ясла повні?" лягла почута Панасом від візника розповідь про реальну особо полтавського розбійника Василя Гнидку, під враженням від цієї розповіді Панас написав нарис "подоріжжя від Полтави до Гадячого"

Answer 2

Introduction

The work "Хіба ревуть воли, як ясла повні?" by Panas Myrny is considered to be a realistic piece of literature. In this response, we will explore the reasons why this work can be classified as realistic and provide arguments to support this claim.

Realism in "Хіба ревуть воли, як ясла повні?"

1. Depiction of everyday life: One of the key characteristics of realism is the portrayal of ordinary, everyday life. "Хіба ревуть воли, як ясла повні?" focuses on the lives of Ukrainian peasants in the late 19th century. It provides a detailed and realistic account of their struggles, joys, and relationships [[1]].

2. Attention to detail: Realistic literature often pays close attention to detail, describing the environment, characters, and events in a meticulous manner. Panas Myrny's work is known for its vivid descriptions of the Ukrainian countryside, the peasants' homes, and their way of life. These details help create a realistic and immersive reading experience [[2]].

3. Social commentary: Realistic literature often aims to reflect and comment on the social, economic, and political realities of the time. "Хіба ревуть воли, як ясла повні?" addresses various social issues faced by Ukrainian peasants, such as poverty, exploitation, and the struggle for land ownership. It sheds light on the harsh conditions and challenges they faced, providing social commentary on the inequalities of the time [[3]].

4. Character development: Realistic literature often focuses on the development and complexity of its characters. In "Хіба ревуть воли, як ясла повні?", the characters are portrayed with depth and nuance. They have their own motivations, desires, and flaws, making them relatable and human. This attention to character development adds to the realism of the work [[4]].

5. Authentic dialogue: Realistic literature often emphasizes authentic dialogue that reflects the language and speech patterns of the time and place depicted. "Хіба ревуть воли, як ясла повні?" captures the authentic language and dialects of Ukrainian peasants, adding to the overall realism of the work [[5]].

Conclusion

"Хіба ревуть воли, як ясла повні?" by Panas Myrny can be considered a realistic work of literature due to its depiction of everyday life, attention to detail, social commentary, character development, and authentic dialogue. These elements contribute to the overall realism of the work and make it a valuable piece of Ukrainian literature.