Question

бернард шоу как-то написал:"если у вас есть яблоко и у меня есть яблоко и если мы обменяемся этими яблоками то у вас и у меня останется по одному яблоку.а если у вас есть идея и у меня есть идея и мы обмениваемся этими идеями то у каждого будет по две идеи" О каких правах идёт речь, если посмотреть на данную ситуацию с позиции гражданского права?

Answer 1

Каждый имеет право свободно искать, получать, передавать, производить и распространять информацию любым законным способом. Каждый имеет право на свободное использование своих способностей и имущества для предпринимательской и иной не запрещенной законом экономической деятельности.

Answer 2

Bernard Shaw's Quote and Civil Law

The quote you mentioned is attributed to George Bernard Shaw, who said, "If you have an apple and I have an apple and we exchange these apples, then you and I will still each have one apple. But if you have an idea and I have an idea and we exchange these ideas, then each of us will have two ideas." This quote highlights the difference between tangible goods (apples) and intangible concepts (ideas) and the potential for ideas to multiply when shared.

When considering this situation from the perspective of civil law, it's important to note that civil law primarily deals with the rights and obligations of individuals and entities in their interactions with each other. In this context, the quote can be interpreted as emphasizing the unique nature of ideas and the potential for their value to increase when shared.

While civil law may not explicitly address the exchange of ideas in the same way it does tangible goods, it does provide protection for intellectual property rights. Intellectual property laws, such as copyright and patent laws, aim to safeguard the rights of individuals and entities who create and share ideas, inventions, and creative works. These laws grant exclusive rights to the creators, allowing them to control the use and dissemination of their ideas and creations.

In the case of exchanging ideas, civil law may come into play when it comes to issues such as intellectual property rights, confidentiality agreements, non-disclosure agreements, and contracts. For example, if two individuals or entities exchange ideas with the intention of collaborating on a project, they may enter into a contract that outlines the terms of their collaboration, including the ownership and use of the ideas generated during the collaboration.

It's important to consult legal professionals or refer to specific legal jurisdictions to obtain more detailed information on how civil law addresses the exchange of ideas and the rights and obligations associated with it.