Question

Владелец аукционного дома доктор искусствоведения Еликян во время пребывания в служебном кабинете заместителя начальника управления культуры Министерства Цальникова в связи с дачей объяснений по результатам проведенной в аукционном доме проверки обратил внимание на украшающую кабинет картину. Еликян высказал восхищение техникой исполнения, восторженно отозвавшись о ранее не встречавшемся стиле исполнения, сочетающем технику постмодернизма с элементами примитивизма и импрессионизма. Уточнив, что полотно исполнено не, как предполагал Еликян, Нико Пиросмани, а Цальниковым совместно с его 7-летней дочерью Ефросиньей и принадлежит Цальникову, так как является подарком, полученным им на 23 февраля, Еликян предложил выставить полотно на аукцион с предварительной оценкой 10 тыс. долларов США. Каким образом следует поступить Цальникову?

Answer 1

Ответ:

Отказаться от столь щедрого предложения, смахивающего на завуалированную взятку.

Объяснение:

Answer 2

Background Information

The owner of an auction house, Dr. Elikyan, noticed a painting hanging in the office of the Deputy Head of the Cultural Department of the Ministry, Mr. Tsalnikov, during a visit to provide explanations following an inspection of the auction house. Dr. Elikyan expressed admiration for the painting's technique and the unique combination of postmodernism, primitivism, and impressionism. However, he later discovered that the painting was not by Niko Pirosmani, as he initially thought, but was actually a joint work by Mr. Tsalnikov and his 7-year-old daughter, Euphrosyne. The painting was a gift received by Mr. Tsalnikov on February 23rd. Dr. Elikyan suggested putting the painting up for auction with an estimated value of $10,000 USD. The question is how Mr. Tsalnikov should proceed in this situation.

Response

Based on the information provided, Mr. Tsalnikov should consider the following options:

1. Consult with a professional art appraiser: Mr. Tsalnikov could seek the advice of an art appraiser to determine the true value of the painting. An expert opinion would help him make an informed decision about whether to proceed with the auction or explore other options.

2. Consider the sentimental value: Since the painting was a gift from his daughter, Mr. Tsalnikov may attach sentimental value to it. He should take this into account when deciding whether to sell the painting or keep it for personal reasons.

3. Evaluate the potential demand: Mr. Tsalnikov should assess the potential demand for the painting in the art market. If there is a significant interest in the artwork, it may be worth considering the auction option. However, if the demand is low, he might explore other avenues to showcase or display the painting.

4. Discuss with Dr. Elikyan: Mr. Tsalnikov could have a conversation with Dr. Elikyan to understand his perspective and reasoning behind suggesting the auction. This discussion may provide additional insights and help Mr. Tsalnikov make an informed decision.

5. Consider alternative options: If Mr. Tsalnikov decides not to proceed with the auction, he could explore other ways to showcase the painting. For example, he could consider displaying it in a public space within the Ministry or donating it to a cultural institution where it can be appreciated by a wider audience.

It is important for Mr. Tsalnikov to carefully consider these options and make a decision that aligns with his personal preferences and the best interests of the artwork.