Question

Докажите что рассказанная пугачевым история сказка​

Answer 1

Ответ:

так как она выдумал с ума это подтвердил гринёв

Answer 2

Analysis of Pugachev's story

The story recounted by Yemelyan Pugachev about his supposed royal lineage has been a topic of debate among historians. Some key points regarding this:

Pugachev claimed to be Tsar Peter III, who was overthrown and killed by his wife Catherine the Great in 1762. However, there is no concrete evidence to prove that his story was true.

Contemporaneous accounts raise doubts about Pugachev's story. During his rebellion in 1773-1775, Pugachev gathered a large peasant following by posing as the rightful Tsar, but officials close to Catherine were skeptical of his claims.

His mannerisms and speech did not match that of royalty. According to eyewitnesses, Pugachev behaved more like a Cossack than a royal, and made many grammatical mistakes inconsistent with someone of noble birth.

No records support his royal lineage. Extensive archives from the era contain no documents linking Pugachev to the royal family. His story emerged years later in exile, with no means to verify it.

His rebellion had clear political goals. While he may have used his supposed identity to rally supporters, Pugachev was actually a disgruntled Don Cossack aiming to address social injustices through revolt.

In summary, while Pugachev's story cannot be definitively disproven, the majority of evidence suggests it was a fabrication aimed at legitimizing his rebellion by posing as the rightful Tsar. His lineage remains uncertain, but most historians consider his account to be a legend rather than proven fact.