Question

Почему объединили два стихотворения А.Т. Твардовского "Я знаю,никакой моей вины..."и Б.А.Слуцкого "Лошади в океане"в одном задании?подсказка"без вины виноватые"Помогите пожалуйста с ответом

Answer 1

В этих стихотворение есть смысл  стихотвроние почти одинаковый по смыслу  и 2 стихотворение есть смысл как у 1 стиха  это как продолжение

Answer 2

The Unification of Two Poems: "Я знаю, никакой моей вины..." by A.T. Tvardovsky and "Лошади в океане" by B.A. Slutsky

The unification of two poems, "Я знаю, никакой моей вины..." by A.T. Tvardovsky and "Лошади в океане" by B.A. Slutsky, in one assignment may be due to their thematic similarities and the shared concept of "без вины виноватые" (innocent but guilty). Both poems explore the idea of individuals who are unjustly blamed or burdened by circumstances beyond their control.

"Я знаю, никакой моей вины..." is a poem by A.T. Tvardovsky, a prominent Soviet poet. It reflects on the experiences of soldiers during World War II and the emotional toll of war. The poem emphasizes the innocence of the soldiers who were forced into battle and highlights the contradiction between their guiltless nature and the guilt they are made to bear. The phrase "без вины виноватые" encapsulates this theme.

"Лошади в океане" is a poem by B.A. Slutsky, another notable Soviet poet. It explores the theme of innocence and guilt through the metaphor of horses in the ocean. The horses, representing innocent beings, are placed in a foreign and hostile environment, symbolizing the burden of guilt they carry despite their lack of fault.

The unification of these two poems in one assignment could be a way for students or readers to compare and contrast the themes, imagery, and poetic techniques used by the two poets. It allows for a deeper exploration of the concept of "без вины виноватые" and its significance in different contexts.

Please note that the information provided above is based on search results and may not cover all possible interpretations or reasons for the unification of these two poems.