Question

Помогите. сравните образы в поэме некрасова "крестьянские дети" и в рассказе распутина "уроки французского". есть ли что- то объединяющее детство 19-20 веков? в чем различия? кто приходит на помощь в трудную минуту?

Answer 1

Ну там объеденяюшего такого не чего нету

Answer 2

Comparing the Depiction of Childhood in Nekrasov's "Peasant Children" and Rasputin's "French Lessons"

In Nekrasov's poem "Peasant Children" and Rasputin's story "French Lessons," the portrayal of childhood in the 19th and 20th centuries respectively reflects both similarities and differences.

Similarities: - Both works depict the challenges and hardships faced by children in rural settings, highlighting the struggles of peasant life and the impact of poverty on childhood.

Differences: - Nekrasov's "Peasant Children" portrays the innocence and simplicity of rural life, emphasizing the close connection between children and nature, while Rasputin's "French Lessons" delves into the complexities of modernization and the influence of foreign culture on the upbringing of children.

Unifying Aspects of Childhood in the 19th and 20th Centuries

Despite the temporal and cultural disparities, certain unifying aspects of childhood can be identified across the 19th and 20th centuries. Both periods witnessed the resilience of children in the face of adversity, the importance of familial bonds, and the formative influence of the surrounding environment on their development.

Differences in Childhood Experiences

The differences in childhood experiences between the 19th and 20th centuries are primarily rooted in the evolving socio-economic and cultural landscapes. The 19th-century childhood, as depicted in Nekrasov's poem, is characterized by the rustic simplicity of rural life, whereas the 20th-century childhood, as portrayed in Rasputin's story, grapples with the encroachment of modernity and the influx of external influences.

Assistance in Times of Hardship

In both works, the concept of community and familial support emerges as a recurring theme. Whether it is the solidarity of the peasant community in Nekrasov's poem or the familial bonds in Rasputin's story, the notion of seeking and providing assistance in difficult times is a common thread that underscores the resilience of the human spirit across different eras.

In conclusion, while Nekrasov's "Peasant Children" and Rasputin's "French Lessons" offer distinct perspectives on childhood in the 19th and 20th centuries, they both shed light on the enduring themes of resilience, familial bonds, and the impact of the environment on the formative years of children.