Question

Можно ли оправдать Дубровского, который создал разбойничий отряд?

Answer 1

Можно. Он сделал это от безысходности. Ведь его старый отец умер,не выдержав издевательств своего "друга" Троекурова,отобравшего родовое поместьею.Он сжег поместье и с преданными слугами отправился  разбойничать. Это можно объяснить тем,что Владимир  не смог оставить ,человеку ненавистному, память о самых близких для Дубровского людях

Answer 2

Understanding Dubrovsky's Actions

Dubrovsky's creation of a band of brigands raises ethical and legal questions. It's important to consider various perspectives when evaluating his actions.

Ethical Considerations

Creating a band of brigands involves engaging in criminal activities, which raises ethical concerns. It's essential to consider the impact of such actions on the well-being and rights of others. Additionally, the motivations behind Dubrovsky's actions and the potential harm caused by his band should be taken into account.

Legal Perspective

From a legal standpoint, Dubrovsky's actions would likely be considered unlawful. Engaging in criminal activities, such as forming a band of brigands, is typically prohibited by law and subject to legal consequences.

Contextual Factors

Understanding the context in which Dubrovsky operated is crucial. Factors such as social, political, and economic conditions at the time may have influenced his decision to create a band of brigands. It's important to consider these contextual factors when evaluating the justifiability of his actions.

Conclusion

While it's important to consider the context and motivations behind Dubrovsky's actions, creating a band of brigands is generally considered unethical and illegal. It's essential to uphold ethical and legal standards while also seeking to understand the underlying reasons for such actions.