Question

Почему рассказ Шолохова "Судьба человека" не рождает чувства безысходности? Тема сочинения))заранее спасибо!) У этого сайта нет рейтинга

Answer 1

Наверное, каждый в жизни задумывался о том, что его проблемы намного серьезнее других. Но когда ты знакомишься с главным героем рассказа Шолохова "Судьба человека"  Андреем Соколовым и его судьбой, то ты сразу понимаешь, что твои проблемы настолько ничтожны по сравнению с тем, что у него случилось в жизни. Он потерял всю свою семью (жену, дочь и сына), в течение какого-го времени находился в плену, выполнял тяжелую физическую работу, голодал, но при всем этом он не сломался. Андрей Соколов не начал пить, наркоманить, не покончил жизнь самоубийством, а просто принял судьбу такой, какая она есть. Поэтому перед такими людьми надо преклоняться. 

Answer 2

The Theme of Desperation in Sholokhov's "The Fate of a Man"

"The Fate of a Man" is a short story written by Mikhail Sholokhov. It tells the story of a Russian soldier, Andrei Sokolov, who experiences the hardships and tragedies of war during World War II. While the story explores the themes of loss, suffering, and resilience, it does not necessarily evoke a sense of hopelessness or despair. Instead, it emphasizes the indomitable human spirit and the ability to find meaning and purpose even in the face of adversity.

The story follows Andrei Sokolov's journey from being a prisoner of war to his eventual return home. Throughout his experiences, Sokolov encounters numerous challenges, including hunger, cold, and the loss of loved ones. However, despite these hardships, he manages to find strength and hope in his determination to survive and reunite with his family.

One reason why "The Fate of a Man" may not evoke a sense of hopelessness is the emphasis on human resilience and the will to live. Despite the difficult circumstances, Sokolov never gives up and continues to fight for his survival. This resilience is highlighted through his resourcefulness, adaptability, and unwavering determination to overcome the obstacles he faces.

Additionally, the story also explores the theme of the importance of human connections and relationships. Sokolov's love for his family and his desire to be reunited with them serve as a driving force throughout the narrative. This emphasis on the power of love and the bonds between individuals adds a sense of purpose and meaning to Sokolov's journey, counteracting any feelings of hopelessness.

It is important to note that interpretations of literary works can vary, and different readers may perceive the themes and emotions differently. While "The Fate of a Man" may not explicitly evoke a sense of despair or hopelessness, readers may still experience a range of emotions and interpretations based on their own perspectives and experiences.

Overall, "The Fate of a Man" by Mikhail Sholokhov explores themes of resilience, hope, and the power of human connections. It portrays the indomitable spirit of the protagonist, Andrei Sokolov, as he navigates the challenges of war and strives to find meaning and purpose in his life.