Question

Помогииииииииииииииитееееееееееееееееееее))))))) Чем отличается любовь Аксиньи и Григория от других отношений? Верно ли что Аксинья и Григорий жертвы своей любви? Почему эта любовь вызывает сочувствие? Их отношения это любовь или беззаконная страсть?

Answer 1

Аргументы за страсть:

- отношения Аксиньи и Григория – супружеская измена с обеих сторон.
- отношения приносят радость только Аксинье и Григорию, но делают несчастными очень многих – например, детей Григория, приводят к ужасной трагедии Наталью.
- материнство Аксиньи уступает перед страстью – она любит не ребенка, а Григория в ребенке.

Аргументы за любовь:

- Сила чувства, верность, неизменность, постоянство.
- Любовь – наперекор всему и преодоление всего, в т. ч. и людского осуждения.
- Любовь Аксиньи и к Аксинье делает Григория лучше, дает ему силы, перерождает его.

Страсть – больше за Аксиньей, любовь – за Григорием.
Страсть обречена на гибель, любовь бессмертна.

В финале романа Аксинья погибает (и ее страсть погибла) , но горе Григория не губит его окончательно (и его любовь продолжает жить) – и он идет к дому с сыном на руках.

Answer 2

The Love between Aksinya and Grigory

The love between Aksinya and Grigory is a central theme in the novel "Quiet Flows the Don" by Mikhail Sholokhov. Their relationship is characterized by several unique aspects that set it apart from other relationships in the story.

1. Sacrifice: Aksinya and Grigory are indeed portrayed as victims of their love. They both make significant sacrifices for the sake of their relationship. Aksinya, who is married to Stepan, risks her reputation and social standing by engaging in an affair with Grigory. Grigory, on the other hand, abandons his dreams of becoming a Cossack officer and leaves his family to be with Aksinya. These sacrifices demonstrate the depth of their love and the lengths they are willing to go to be together.

2. Sympathy: The love between Aksinya and Grigory evokes sympathy because their relationship is marked by tragedy and hardship. They face numerous obstacles, including societal disapproval, betrayal, and the brutal realities of war. Their love is constantly tested, and they endure immense suffering as a result. This evokes a sense of empathy and compassion from the readers, making their love story poignant and relatable.

3. Love or Unlawful Passion: The nature of Aksinya and Grigory's relationship can be seen as a combination of both love and unlawful passion. While their love for each other is undeniable, their actions go against societal norms and moral codes. Aksinya's infidelity and Grigory's abandonment of his family are considered morally wrong in the context of the novel. However, their love is portrayed as genuine and intense, which adds complexity to their relationship.

It is important to note that the analysis above is based on the novel "Quiet Flows the Don" by Mikhail Sholokhov. The interpretation of Aksinya and Grigory's relationship may vary depending on individual perspectives and readings of the novel.