Question

Почему при всех своих положительных качествах герой ни в чем не добивается успеха? Из романа "Дубровский"

Answer 1

1.Ну, можно сказать, что здесь Пушкин заложил одну из черт традиционного русского реалистического романа. В последующие почти уже двести лет положительные герои реалистической русской прозы очень редко будут добиваться успеха. Особенно это касается ХОРОШЕЙ русской прозы. А в жизни разве иначе? Награда за положительные качества личности - в самих этих качествах, а совсем не в поверхностном жизненном успехе.

 

2. Пушкин описывал жизнь, современные нравы. По-другому быть не могло. А потом - мы ведь не знаем, как сложилась его дальнейшая жизнь...

Answer 2

The Character of the Hero in "Dubrovsky"

In the novel "Dubrovsky," the hero is portrayed as having many positive qualities, yet he fails to achieve success in any aspect of his life. This can be attributed to several factors within the story.

One possible reason for the hero's lack of success is his rebellious nature and his refusal to conform to societal norms. The character of Dubrovsky is depicted as a nobleman who becomes disillusioned with the corrupt and oppressive system of his time. He takes matters into his own hands and seeks justice outside of the established legal framework. While his intentions may be noble, his actions ultimately lead to his downfall and prevent him from achieving success.

Another factor that contributes to the hero's lack of success is his inability to adapt to changing circumstances. Throughout the novel, Dubrovsky finds himself in various situations that require him to adjust his approach and strategy. However, he remains stubborn and refuses to compromise his principles, which ultimately hinders his progress.

Furthermore, the hero's uncompromising nature and his tendency to prioritize personal vendettas over practical considerations also play a role in his lack of success. Dubrovsky becomes consumed by his desire for revenge against those who have wronged him, and this obsession blinds him to the potential consequences of his actions. As a result, he fails to make strategic decisions that could have led to a more favorable outcome.

It is also worth noting that the hero's lack of success can be attributed to external factors beyond his control. The novel is set in a time of political and social upheaval, where the established order is crumbling. This chaotic environment makes it difficult for individuals like Dubrovsky to find stability and achieve their goals.

In conclusion, the hero in "Dubrovsky" possesses many positive qualities, but his inability to conform, adapt, and prioritize effectively prevents him from achieving success. His rebellious nature, refusal to compromise, and obsession with personal vendettas contribute to his downfall. Additionally, the turbulent historical context in which the story takes place further complicates his pursuit of success.