Question

Ответы почему он живой и светится нельзя назвать народной сказкой

Answer 1

Потому что написал человек.

Answer 2

Why "He's Alive and Glowing" Can't Be Called a Folk Tale

The story "He's Alive and Glowing" cannot be classified as a folk tale due to several reasons. Firstly, the tale does not align with the traditional characteristics and themes of folk tales. Folk tales typically involve elements of oral tradition, cultural significance, and a moral or lesson for the audience. However, "He's Alive and Glowing" does not exhibit these typical folk tale traits.

Additionally, the story lacks the historical and cultural roots that are often associated with folk tales. Folk tales are usually deeply rooted in the history and traditions of a particular culture or community, serving as a reflection of their values and beliefs. In contrast, "He's Alive and Glowing" does not demonstrate a clear connection to any specific cultural or historical context.

Furthermore, the absence of widespread oral transmission and variation also sets "He's Alive and Glowing" apart from traditional folk tales. Folk tales are typically passed down orally from generation to generation, leading to variations in the narrative and allowing for cultural adaptation. However, "He's Alive and Glowing" does not exhibit this characteristic of oral tradition and cultural adaptation.

In conclusion, the story "He's Alive and Glowing" does not meet the criteria for a folk tale due to its deviation from the traditional characteristics, themes, historical roots, and oral transmission typically associated with folk tales.