Question

Дати Сравни поведение главных героев произведений Л.Н. Толстого «Кавказский пленник» иВ.П. Астафьева «Конь с розовой гривой». Как ведут себя герои в ситуации нравственного выбора:Жилин в эпизоде обмана малого и Витя в эпизоде обмана бабушки? Можно ли оправдать ихповедение поговоркой «Ложь во спасение»? Почему? Испытывакт ли герои муки совести послесвоего поступка? Как этот поступок повлиял на дальнейшую жизнь героя?​

Answer 1

Ответ:

1. Жилин ведёт себя нормально, пытается сбежать, а Витя хотел Коня с розовой головой поэтому обманул бабушку

2. Витя обманул бабушку и ему было стыдно

Жилин не хотел чтобы его убили и хотел сбежать к своим

3. да, потому что они хотели спастись Витя от того что бабушка накажет ю, а Жилин от гибели

4.Витя да, а Жилин нет, Жилин вернулся в Кавказ, а Витю простила бабушка.

— Можно лучший ответ?

Answer 2

Comparison of the Behavior of the Main Characters in "The Caucasian Prisoner" by L.N. Tolstoy and "The Horse with the Pink Mane" by V.P. Astafyev

In "The Caucasian Prisoner" by Leo Tolstoy and "The Horse with the Pink Mane" by Vasily Astafyev, the main characters face moral dilemmas and are forced to make choices that have significant consequences. Let's compare the behavior of the characters Zhilin in the episode of deceiving a young boy and Vitya in the episode of deceiving his grandmother.

Zhilin's Behavior in the Episode of Deceiving the Young Boy

In "The Caucasian Prisoner," Zhilin, the main character, finds himself in a situation where he has to deceive a young boy named Semyon. Zhilin pretends to be a French officer and promises to help Semyon's father, who is a prisoner of war. Zhilin's intention is to gain the trust of Semyon and use him to escape from captivity.

Zhilin's behavior can be seen as manipulative and morally questionable. He takes advantage of the young boy's innocence and trust to further his own agenda. However, it is important to note that Zhilin's actions are driven by his desire to escape and survive in a hostile environment.

Vitya's Behavior in the Episode of Deceiving His Grandmother

In "The Horse with the Pink Mane," Vitya, the main character, deceives his grandmother by pretending to be a successful student. He fabricates stories about his achievements and academic progress to gain her approval and admiration. Vitya's intention is to avoid disappointing his grandmother and to maintain a positive image in her eyes.

Vitya's behavior can also be seen as deceptive and morally questionable. He lies to his grandmother, betraying her trust and creating a false image of himself. However, like Zhilin, Vitya's actions are driven by his desire to please his grandmother and avoid disappointing her.

Can Their Behavior Be Justified by the Saying "A Lie for the Sake of Salvation"?

The saying "A lie for the sake of salvation" suggests that lying can be justified if it serves a greater purpose or prevents harm. In the cases of Zhilin and Vitya, their lies can be seen as attempts to protect themselves or others from potential harm or disappointment. However, it is important to consider the consequences of their actions and whether the harm caused by their lies outweighs the potential benefits.

Do the Characters Experience Guilt or Remorse After Their Actions?

Both Zhilin and Vitya experience inner turmoil and guilt after their deceptive actions. In "The Caucasian Prisoner," Zhilin feels remorse for deceiving Semyon and acknowledges the moral ambiguity of his actions. Similarly, in "The Horse with the Pink Mane," Vitya feels guilty for lying to his grandmother and experiences a sense of shame.

Impact of Their Actions on the Characters' Future Lives

The deceptive actions of Zhilin and Vitya have lasting consequences on their lives. In "The Caucasian Prisoner," Zhilin's deceit leads to a series of events that ultimately result in his capture and imprisonment. His actions not only affect his own fate but also impact the lives of those around him.

In "The Horse with the Pink Mane," Vitya's lies create a false image of himself, which becomes difficult to maintain. As he grows older, Vitya realizes the importance of honesty and struggles to reconcile his past actions with his present self.

In conclusion, the behavior of the main characters in "The Caucasian Prisoner" and "The Horse with the Pink Mane" involves moral dilemmas and choices with significant consequences. While their actions can be seen as morally questionable, they are driven by their circumstances and desires. The saying "A lie for the sake of salvation" can be used to discuss the justification of their behavior, but it is important to consider the consequences and the characters' feelings of guilt and remorse. Ultimately, their actions have a lasting impact on their lives and the lives of those around them.