Question

о Прочитайте монолог, выражая интонацией душевное состояние Сальери. P Сальери считает, что мир построен на несправедливости, потому что в искусстве важны не любовь к музыке, не самоотверженный и упорный труд, а дар, который приходит неизвестно кому и неиз- вестно за что. Вот в чём глубочайшая несправедливость. У Сальери возникает зависть к ничтожному, на его взгляд, человеку, которому по ошибке достался величайший талант. В представлении Сальери такой дар должен достаться только такому, как он, человеку. Как вы считаете, прав ли Сальери? Чем определяется дар человека? По- делитесь своим мнением. OCTOBW1 109​

Answer 1

Ответ:

Я согласен с Сальери, потому что это лекарство от бога. Это должно быть дано только правильному человеку

Объяснение:

это правильно!

Answer 2

Salieri's Monologue and the Injustice of Talent Distribution

In the monologue, Salieri expresses his belief that the world is built on injustice because in art, what matters is not love for music or dedicated hard work, but rather a gift that comes to someone unknown and for unknown reasons. Salieri feels a deep sense of injustice because he envies someone he considers insignificant, who mistakenly received the greatest talent. According to Salieri's perspective, such a gift should only be given to someone like himself.

Salieri's viewpoint raises an interesting question about the nature of talent and how it is determined. Let's explore this further.

Is Salieri Right? What Determines a Person's Talent?

Salieri's belief that talent should be distributed based on merit, rather than randomly bestowed, is a matter of personal opinion. While it is natural for individuals to desire recognition for their hard work and dedication, the concept of talent itself is complex and multifaceted.

Talent can be influenced by a combination of factors, including genetics, environment, upbringing, exposure to opportunities, and personal motivation. Some individuals may possess innate abilities or predispositions that make it easier for them to excel in certain areas. However, talent alone is not enough to guarantee success. Hard work, perseverance, and continuous learning are also crucial elements in achieving mastery in any field.

It is important to note that talent is not a fixed attribute. It can be developed and nurtured through practice, education, and experience. While some individuals may have a natural inclination towards a particular skill, others can acquire and refine their talents through dedicated effort.

The Role of Luck and Chance

Salieri's frustration stems from the belief that talent is distributed arbitrarily, without regard for deserving individuals. However, it is worth considering the role of luck and chance in the development of talent. Sometimes, individuals with immense potential may go unnoticed or lack the necessary opportunities to fully realize their abilities. Conversely, others may receive recognition or opportunities that they did not necessarily earn.

In the world of art and creativity, there are countless examples of individuals who achieved great success despite not possessing the most exceptional talent. Factors such as timing, networking, and luck can play a significant role in an artist's career trajectory. However, it is also important to acknowledge that talent alone cannot guarantee success without hard work, dedication, and a genuine passion for the craft.

Conclusion

Salieri's perspective on the injustice of talent distribution in the world of art is a subjective viewpoint. While it is natural to desire recognition for one's efforts, talent is a complex and multifaceted concept that is influenced by various factors. While some individuals may possess innate abilities, talent can also be developed and nurtured through hard work and dedication.

It is important to recognize that luck and chance can play a role in an individual's success, but they are not the sole determinants. Ultimately, the combination of talent, hard work, opportunity, and personal motivation contributes to an individual's achievements in any field.

Note: The information provided above is based on general knowledge and does not cite specific sources.