Question

В 751 году Пипин Короткий спросил римского папу:" Кто должен управлять государством: короли, которые носят это звание, не имея королевской власти,или те,кто реально управляют государством?" Папа ответил,что лучше называть королем того,кто имеет власть,чем того,кто ее лишен. Как вы думаете,почему папа так ответил Пипину? Как король отблагодарил папу?

Answer 1

Какая система власти была создана в крае?можно ли эту систему власти назвать многовластием??

Answer 2

The Response:

In 751, Pepin the Short, the King of the Franks, approached the Pope with a question regarding who should govern the state: the kings who hold the title without actual royal power, or those who effectively govern the state. The Pope responded that it is better to call the one who holds power a king rather than someone who is deprived of it. The reason behind the Pope's response and how the king thanked the Pope are not explicitly mentioned in the search results. However, we can speculate on possible reasons based on historical context.

One possible reason for the Pope's response is that he wanted to maintain a good relationship with Pepin the Short, who was the ruler of the Franks and a powerful figure in Europe at the time. By acknowledging Pepin's authority and legitimizing his rule, the Pope could secure his support and protection for the Church. This could have been a strategic move to strengthen the alliance between the Papacy and the Frankish Kingdom.

As for how the king thanked the Pope, the search results do not provide specific information. However, it is reasonable to assume that Pepin the Short, being a devout Christian and recognizing the Pope's authority, would have expressed his gratitude and respect for the Pope's response. The exact details of their interaction and any specific gestures of gratitude are not available in the provided search results.

In summary, the Pope's response to Pepin the Short's question about who should govern the state was likely influenced by the desire to maintain a positive relationship with the powerful Frankish king. The exact reasons behind the Pope's response and the king's expression of gratitude are not explicitly mentioned in the search results.