Question

Существует точка зрения что несмотря на наличие существенных отличий в деятельности первого и второго ополчения в годы Смуты было много общего

Answer 1

1) Сохранились летописные произведения, описывающие исторические события.

2) Сохранилась церковная литература (например, жития святых).

Answer 2

Commonalities Between the First and Second Volunteer Armies During the Time of Troubles

There is a viewpoint that despite significant differences in the activities of the First and Second Volunteer Armies during the Time of Troubles, there were many commonalities.

1. Context of the Time of Troubles: - The Time of Troubles was a period of political crisis in Russia that followed the demise of the Rurik dynasty. It involved a series of uprisings, invasions, and civil wars. - The First Volunteer Army was formed during the early stages of the Russian Civil War, while the Second Volunteer Army operated during the later stages of the conflict.

2. Shared Objectives: - Both the First and Second Volunteer Armies aimed to combat various opposing forces and establish control over territories. - The armies were involved in military operations and engagements to achieve their respective goals.

3. Leadership and Organization: - The leadership structure and organization of the First and Second Volunteer Armies may have exhibited similarities in terms of command, hierarchy, and decision-making processes.

4. Challenges Faced: - Both armies likely encountered similar challenges related to resources, logistics, and the overall conduct of military operations during a period of widespread conflict and instability.

5. Impact on the Time of Troubles: - The activities and contributions of the First and Second Volunteer Armies may have had a significant impact on the overall course and outcome of the Time of Troubles in Russia.

It's important to note that the specific details of the commonalities between the First and Second Volunteer Armies during the Time of Troubles would require a more in-depth analysis of historical sources and scholarly works.