Question

Почему было важно, что обряд коронования Карла Великого был проведён с участием духовного лица?

Answer 1

Потому что церковь тогда стояла на раане с королевским двором т. е. наравне с императором, королем, царем.

Answer 2

Importance of the Involvement of a Spiritual Figure in the Coronation of Charlemagne

The coronation of Charlemagne with the involvement of a spiritual figure was important for several reasons. Here are some key points to consider:

1. Religious Legitimacy: The involvement of a spiritual figure in the coronation of Charlemagne added religious legitimacy to his rule. In the Middle Ages, religion played a central role in society, and the support of the Church was crucial for the legitimacy of rulers. By having a spiritual figure, such as the Pope, participate in the coronation, it symbolized the approval and blessing of the Church on Charlemagne's reign.

2. Divine Right of Kings: The involvement of a spiritual figure in the coronation ceremony also reinforced the concept of the divine right of kings. According to this belief, monarchs derived their authority directly from God. By having a spiritual figure present, it emphasized the idea that Charlemagne's rule was ordained by God and that he had a sacred duty to govern his kingdom.

3. Symbolic Unity of Church and State: The involvement of a spiritual figure in the coronation ceremony represented the unity of the Church and the state. Charlemagne's empire was known as the Holy Roman Empire, and the coronation ceremony symbolized the close relationship between the spiritual and temporal powers. It demonstrated that Charlemagne's rule was not only political but also had a religious dimension.

4. Political Alliances: The involvement of a spiritual figure in the coronation ceremony also had political implications. Charlemagne sought to strengthen his political alliances by aligning himself with the Church. By having the Pope or another high-ranking clergy member participate in the coronation, it solidified the relationship between Charlemagne and the Church, which could provide him with support and influence in his rule.

5. Historical Precedent: The involvement of a spiritual figure in the coronation of Charlemagne followed a long-standing tradition in European history. Throughout the Middle Ages, the coronation of kings and emperors often involved the participation of religious leaders. This tradition helped to establish a sense of continuity and legitimacy for rulers, as they were following in the footsteps of their predecessors.

In conclusion, the involvement of a spiritual figure in the coronation of Charlemagne was important for religious legitimacy, the concept of divine right, the symbolic unity of Church and state, political alliances, and historical precedent. It added a sense of religious and political legitimacy to Charlemagne's rule and reinforced the close relationship between the Church and the state in medieval Europe.