Question

Признать целесообразным заключение договора между советскими республиками Украины, Белоруссии, Азербайджана, Грузии, Армении и РСФСР о формальном вступлении первых в состав РСФСР о чем идет речь в документе? подробнее расскажите о предлагаемом варианте объединения республик. какие были ещё возможные варианты объединения республик?

Answer 1

ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ СССР (1922-1924 гг.)

Шесть советских социалистических республик: РСФСР, УССР, БССР, Азербайджанская ССР, Армянская ССР, Грузинская ССР и две народные советские республики: Бухарская (бывшее Бухарское ханство) и Хорезмская (бывшее Хивинское Ханство) продолжали сближение уже в условиях мира. Укреплялись экономические и политические связи. Вот некоторые факты:

- в конце 20-начале 21 г. правительство РСФСР выделило Армянской ССР денежную ссуду в 3 млрд. руб., направило эшелон - с товарами первой необходимости, 325 тыс. пуд. зерна, 5 тыс. пуд. сахара;

- из Азерб. ССР в Армению было послано 50 вагонов хлеба, 36 тыс. пуд. нефти; 

- в 1920 г. в составе РСФСР были провозглашены автономые республики: Туркестанская и Киргизская, всего в состав РСФСР входили 8 автономных республик и II автономных областей;

- в 1920 - 21 гг. между РСФСР и др. республиками были заключены договоры о военно-хозяйственном союзе;

- в 1922 г. на Генуэзской конференции делегация РСФСР представляла все советские республики;

- в марте 1922 г. Грузия, Армения и Азербайджан заключили договор об образовании Закавказской Социалистической Федерации Советских Республик (ЗСФСР).

Answer 2

Proposed Union of Soviet Republics

The document in question refers to the proposal to conclude a treaty between the Soviet republics of Ukraine, Belarus, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Armenia, and the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic (RSFSR) for the formal entry of the former into the RSFSR. This proposed union aimed at formalizing the incorporation of these republics into the RSFSR.

The proposed union of the Soviet republics was a significant political and administrative move that aimed to consolidate the power and influence of the RSFSR over the other republics. This formal entry into the RSFSR was a strategic decision with far-reaching implications for the governance and structure of the Soviet Union.

Details of the Proposed Union

The proposed union involved the formal entry of the aforementioned Soviet republics into the RSFSR. This would have likely resulted in a more centralized governance structure, with the RSFSR exerting greater control and influence over the other republics. The specifics of the proposed union would have included legal, administrative, and possibly economic integration of the republics into the RSFSR.

The proposed union also aimed to address various political, economic, and administrative challenges faced by the Soviet Union at the time. It sought to streamline governance and decision-making processes, potentially leading to a more cohesive and centralized system.

Possible Alternatives for Union

While the proposed union aimed at formalizing the entry of the republics into the RSFSR, there were other possible alternatives for the union of the Soviet republics. These alternatives could have included different forms of confederations, alliances, or federations among the republics, each with varying degrees of autonomy and centralization.

Other possible alternatives might have involved the creation of a more decentralized system, where the republics retained a higher degree of independence and self-governance. These alternatives would have likely resulted in different power dynamics and administrative structures within the Soviet Union.

The decision to pursue the formal entry of the republics into the RSFSR reflects a specific approach to addressing the challenges and opportunities presented by the political landscape at the time.

For more detailed information, you can refer to the provided sources for a comprehensive understanding of the historical and political context surrounding the proposed union of the Soviet republics.