Question

Приход большевиков к власти,это Еще одна революция или октябрьский переворот?Надо доказать что это именно . Привести аргументы или опровержения,если есть

Answer 1

Так то революция и переворот , это одно и тоже ,но различие заключается в том что переворот это ( например: свержение правителя ) А революция - это коренное изменение как бы ( например: свержение правителя и изменение системы управления ) так как большевики изменили систему управления и конечно же свергли Правителя , мы можем смело прийти к выводу , что это революция . ( Надеюсь помог)

Answer 2

Bolsheviks' Rise to Power: Another Revolution or October Coup?

The Bolsheviks' rise to power in 1917 is commonly referred to as the October Revolution. This event marked the seizure of power by the Bolshevik Party, led by Vladimir Lenin, and the beginning of the Soviet era in Russia. The term "October Revolution" is widely used to describe this pivotal moment in Russian history.

Arguments for the October Revolution: 1. Historical Consensus: The prevailing historical consensus refers to the Bolsheviks' rise to power as the October Revolution. This term is widely accepted and used in historical and academic contexts. 2. Timing: The events unfolded in October 1917 according to the Julian calendar, which was in use in Russia at the time. This aligns with the naming of the revolution as the October Revolution. 3. Bolshevik Seizure of Power: The Bolshevik Party, through a series of strategic moves and support from the working class and the military, effectively seized power in Petrograd and Moscow in October 1917, leading to the establishment of a new government.

Arguments against Another Revolution: 1. Semantic Interpretation: Some may argue that the term "revolution" implies a broader societal upheaval, while the Bolsheviks' rise to power was more of a targeted political coup. However, this is a matter of semantic interpretation and does not negate the widely accepted use of the term "October Revolution".

In conclusion, the prevailing historical consensus and the specific timing and nature of the Bolsheviks' rise to power support the widely accepted designation of this event as the October Revolution.

If you have further questions or need additional information, feel free to ask!