Question

Илюша получил новое письмо от Васи. Подчеркни те высказывания которые ты считаешь ошибочными. Мы с родителями ехали на дачу, когда в вагон вошли 2 девушки и начали продавать книги о единственном правильном Боге со сложным именем которое я не запомнил. Они долго приставали к пассажирам и даже угрожали всем, кто не купит книги, что их Бог нашлет на них страшные болезни. Рядом с нами сидела старушка , которая называла их безбожниками и говорила, что всех иноверцев надо посадить в тюрьму. А старичок в конце вагона закричал, что все верующие обманывают людей и их надо всех поместить в больницу для психических больных. Я не понял, кто же из них прав? Помоги Илюше написать ответ другу. Вася, я думаю, что никто из них не прав ЧТО ЛИШНЕЕ ПОДЧЕРКНИ

Answer 1

Рядом с нами сидела старушка , которая называла их безбожниками и говорила, что всех иноверцев надо посадить в тюрьму. 

Answer 2

Analyzing the Situation

It seems like there was a complex and intense situation on the train involving different individuals with strong beliefs. Let's break down the different perspectives and analyze the situation.

Perspectives on the Train

- Two Girls Selling Books: Two girls entered the train and began selling books about the "only true God" with a complex name. They reportedly pressured passengers and threatened those who didn't buy the books with dire consequences from their God. - This behavior seems to have made some passengers uncomfortable and possibly fearful.

- Old Lady: The old lady referred to the girls as "godless" and advocated for imprisoning all non-believers. - Her perspective seems to be rooted in a strong belief in a particular faith and a desire to enforce it on others.

- Old Man: The old man at the end of the train claimed that all believers are deceivers and should be placed in a mental hospital. - His perspective appears to be highly skeptical of all religious beliefs and advocates for institutionalizing believers.

Response to Vasya

Hey Vasya! It sounds like quite a scene on the train. It's understandable that you're confused about who might be right in this situation. Let's break it down.

Evaluating the Perspectives

- Two Girls Selling Books: Their approach of pressuring and threatening passengers doesn't seem respectful or considerate. It's important to share beliefs in a way that respects others' choices and autonomy.

- Old Lady: While it's important to respect different beliefs, advocating for imprisoning non-believers seems extreme and goes against principles of freedom of belief and expression.

- Old Man: Similarly, suggesting that all believers should be placed in a mental hospital is also extreme and doesn't consider the diversity of beliefs and experiences that people have.

Conclusion

It's important to remember that everyone is entitled to their beliefs and should be able to express them without fear of coercion or discrimination. Respect and understanding for different perspectives are key in situations like this. It's okay to have different beliefs, but it's important to express them in a way that respects others.

I hope this helps you navigate this complex situation, Vasya. Let me know if you have any other questions or need further assistance!