Question

можно ли согласиться с мнением некоторых историков о решающем воздействии личных качеств Ивана Грозного на проводимую им политику?

Answer 1

можно, потому что не забывай - он в каком веке вырос то - в 16, определенно его характер сыграл роль в нем как в лидере. в английских учебниках его считают самым кровавым и страшнымЮ хотя если покопаться у них там у самих :) 

ну грозный, у него даже прозвище данное народом говорит за себя. позже его личные качества вылились в опричнину 

Answer 2

Ivan the Terrible's Influence on Policy

Some historians argue that the personal qualities of Ivan the Terrible had a decisive impact on the policies he pursued. Ivan the Terrible, also known as Ivan IV, was the first Tsar of Russia. His reign was marked by significant expansion of the Russian state and the implementation of policies that centralized power. Some historians believe that Ivan's personal qualities, such as his volatile temperament and paranoia, greatly influenced his policies and the way he ruled the country.

Ivan's policies, such as the oprichnina (a state policy of mass repression and terror) and his military campaigns, are often attributed to his personal characteristics. His brutal and authoritarian rule is seen as a reflection of his own personality and the impact it had on the governance of Russia.

However, it's important to note that historical perspectives on this issue can vary, and not all historians may agree on the extent of Ivan the Terrible's personal influence on his policies. Some may argue that broader historical, political, and social factors also played significant roles in shaping the policies of his reign.

In conclusion, while some historians emphasize the decisive influence of Ivan the Terrible's personal qualities on his policies, it's essential to consider a range of perspectives and historical contexts when evaluating the impact of his rule on Russian history.