Question

Почему еретиков,вершившихся в Христа и почитавших Евангелие,католическая церковь подчас преследовала с большей жесткостью и непримиримостью,чем язычников,мусульман и иудеев?

Answer 1

Потому,что они разбирались в нюансах веры и знали тонкие места веры

Answer 2

Persecution of Heretics by the Catholic Church

The persecution of heretics by the Catholic Church was often more severe and uncompromising compared to the treatment of pagans, Muslims, and Jews for several reasons.

Doctrinal Threat: The Catholic Church viewed heretics as a direct threat to its doctrinal purity and authority. Heretics were seen as individuals who deviated from the established teachings of the Church, which was considered a more significant challenge than the beliefs of non-Christians.

Internal Threat: Heretical movements often emerged from within the Christian community, posing a direct internal challenge to the authority and unity of the Church. This internal threat was perceived as more dangerous than external challenges from non-Christian religions.

Impact on Unity: The presence of heretical beliefs within the Christian community was seen as a potential source of division and disunity, which was considered more damaging than the presence of non-Christian religions outside the Church.

Salvation Concerns: The Catholic Church believed that heretical beliefs could lead individuals astray from the path to salvation, which was a significant concern for the Church's leadership.

Response to Challenges: The response to heresy was often characterized by a strong desire to maintain orthodoxy and combat perceived threats to the integrity of the faith, leading to more aggressive measures against heretics.

Legal and Political Factors: In some cases, the persecution of heretics was influenced by legal and political considerations, as the Church sought to maintain its influence and control over the affairs of the state and society.

Conclusion: The Catholic Church's approach to heresy was shaped by doctrinal, internal, and unity concerns, as well as the perceived threat to salvation and the Church's response to challenges. These factors contributed to the more severe and uncompromising treatment of heretics compared to other religious groups.