Question

Объясните разницу между автономией "Алаш" и Туркестанской ( Кокпндской) автономией с точки зрения идеологии?

Answer 1

Ответ:

Алаш:они хотели автономию от россий, они хотели демократическую страну

Туркестан: они хотели обьеденить все средне азиатских тюрков в одну страну

Answer 2

Difference Between Autonomy of "Alash" and Turkestan (Kokand) Autonomy from an Ideological Perspective

The autonomy of "Alash" and Turkestan (Kokand) autonomy differed in their ideological underpinnings.

Alash Autonomy: The Alash Autonomy was a short-lived government in the territory of present-day Kazakhstan, which existed from 1917 to 1920. It was established by the leaders of the Alash Orda movement, who aimed to create an independent Kazakh state. The ideology of Alash Autonomy was rooted in the promotion of Kazakh national identity and the preservation of Kazakh culture and language. The leaders of the Alash movement sought to establish a democratic and secular state that would prioritize the interests of the Kazakh people.

Turkestan (Kokand) Autonomy: On the other hand, Turkestan (Kokand) Autonomy, also known as the Kokand Autonomy, was a short-lived state in Central Asia that existed from 1917 to 1918. It was established by the Kokand Autonomous Government, which aimed to create an autonomous region within the Russian Empire. The ideology of Turkestan Autonomy was influenced by the desire for self-governance and autonomy within the framework of the Russian Empire. The leaders of the Kokand Autonomous Government sought to assert local control over the region's affairs while maintaining a degree of autonomy under the Russian rule.

In summary, the ideological difference between the autonomy of "Alash" and Turkestan (Kokand) autonomy lies in their respective goals and aspirations. While Alash Autonomy aimed for an independent Kazakh state with a focus on national identity and cultural preservation, Turkestan (Kokand) Autonomy sought a degree of self-governance within the framework of the Russian Empire.

I hope this helps to clarify the ideological differences between the two autonomies! If you have further questions or need more information, feel free to ask.