Question

Какое из пиведённых утверждений кажется вам более верным:"Группа подавляет личность и способности подростка," Только в группе подросток проявляет свои способности и таланты"?

Answer 1

Я думаю 1 вариант))))))

Answer 2

Мне кажется, что верно первое утверждение, т.к. подросток может проявить свои способности самостоятельно. Многие знаменитые художники или певцы начинали рисовать или петь самостоятельно. А вот группа может подавить личность и её способности, т.к. она может очень сильно влиять на человека. 

Answer 3

"Группа подавляет личность и способности подростка"

This statement suggests that being part of a group suppresses the individuality and abilities of a teenager.

While it is true that group dynamics can sometimes influence individual behavior and choices, it is important to consider the context and specific circumstances. Group dynamics can have both positive and negative effects on individuals, depending on various factors such as the nature of the group, the level of conformity expected, and the individual's own personality and values.

Research suggests that group dynamics can influence individual behavior in different ways. Some studies have found that group pressure can lead to conformity and the suppression of individual opinions and ideas This can be particularly true in situations where there is a strong desire for social acceptance or when individuals fear rejection or isolation from the group.

However, it is also important to note that groups can provide a supportive and nurturing environment for individuals to express their talents and abilities. In certain contexts, being part of a group can enhance a teenager's self-esteem, provide opportunities for collaboration and learning, and foster the development of social skills and leadership qualities.

In conclusion, it is not accurate to make a blanket statement that "группа подавляет личность и способности подростка" (the group suppresses the personality and abilities of a teenager). The influence of a group on an individual's personality and abilities can vary depending on the specific circumstances and dynamics of the group. It is important to consider the potential positive and negative effects of group dynamics on individual development.

"Только в группе подросток проявляет свои способности и таланты"

This statement suggests that a teenager can only showcase their abilities and talents when they are part of a group.

While it is true that group settings can provide opportunities for individuals to showcase their abilities and talents, it is not the only context in which teenagers can express themselves. Individual talents and abilities can also be nurtured and developed outside of group settings, such as through personal hobbies, individual projects, or one-on-one mentorship.

It is important to recognize that individuals have unique strengths and talents that may not always align with the dynamics and expectations of a group. Some teenagers may feel more comfortable and confident expressing themselves individually rather than in a group setting. Additionally, some talents and abilities may require solitude or focused attention, which may not be conducive to a group environment.

In conclusion, while being part of a group can provide opportunities for teenagers to showcase their abilities and talents, it is not the only context in which they can do so. Individual expression and development should also be valued and encouraged, as different individuals may thrive in different settings.