Question

Русский философ Л.П. Карсавин считал, что субъектом истории является все человечество, которое выступает как реальная "симфоническая личность", существующей в культурах, народах, классах, группах, вплоть до конкретной индивидуальности. Как вы понимаете это утверждение? ПОМОГИТЕ ПОЖАЛУЙСТА!!!!!! ОЧЕНЬ НАДО)))))))

Answer 1

Сочинение или просто как понимаете

Answer 2

Историю создает само общество - своими потребностями, взглядами, действиями.. . власть - она же тоже от народа (выборы).. . менталитет - ведь в одной и той же ситуации каждый народ будет думать и действовать по-своему.. . И очередной учебник по истории - напишет тот же народ.. .

Answer 3

Understanding L.P. Karsavin's Statement

Russian philosopher L.P. Karsavin believed that the subject of history is all of humanity, which acts as a real "symphonic personality" existing in cultures, nations, classes, groups, and even down to individuality. This statement suggests a holistic view of history, where the collective actions and characteristics of humanity as a whole shape the course of historical events.

Karsavin's concept of a "symphonic personality" implies that the diverse elements of humanity, such as cultures, nations, and classes, contribute to a harmonious whole, much like the instruments in an orchestra coming together to create a symphony. This view emphasizes the interconnectedness and interdependence of different human entities in shaping historical developments.

The idea that humanity acts as a "symphonic personality" also suggests that the collective actions and characteristics of humanity are intertwined and influence each other, leading to the development of historical events and the progression of societies over time.

Interpretation of the Statement

Karsavin's assertion can be interpreted as emphasizing the interconnectedness of human history, where the actions and characteristics of various human entities, from broad cultural movements to individual personalities, collectively contribute to the unfolding of historical events. This perspective underscores the significance of understanding history as a complex interplay of diverse human elements rather than isolated events or individuals.

The concept of a "symphonic personality" also implies that the richness and complexity of human history arise from the interactions and collaborations among different cultural, national, and individual identities. This view encourages a holistic understanding of history that considers the collective impact of humanity as a whole on the course of historical developments.

In summary, L.P. Karsavin's statement underscores the interconnected nature of human history, highlighting the collective influence of humanity as a "symphonic personality" that encompasses diverse cultural, national, and individual elements.

Note: The interpretations provided are based on the understanding of L.P. Karsavin's statement and are not direct quotes from the sources provided.