Question

Я живу на девятом этаже,на девятом--это определение,или на девятом этаже--это обстоятельство?

Answer 1

Где? на 9 этаже значит обстоятельство.

Answer 2

На этаже - обстоятельство. (где?)
Девятом - определение (этаже каком?)

Answer 3

Definition vs. Circumstance in Russian Language

In the Russian language, the distinction between "на девятом этаже" (on the ninth floor) as a definition or as a circumstance can be understood based on the context and usage.

Definition vs. Circumstance: - Definition: When "на девятом этаже" is used to define the location or position of something, it functions as a definition. For example, "Моя квартира на девятом этаже" (My apartment is on the ninth floor) defines the specific location of the apartment. - Circumstance: On the other hand, when "на девятом этаже" is used to provide additional information about an action or state, it functions as a circumstance. For instance, "Я живу на девятом этаже" (I live on the ninth floor) provides the circumstance or context in which the action of living takes place.

The distinction between definition and circumstance in this context is based on the grammatical and semantic role of the phrase "на девятом этаже" within the sentence.

(https://pk.mipt.ru/bachelor/2023_olympiads/) (https://pk.mipt.ru/bachelor/2023_olympiads/)