Question

С какого момента, по вашему мнению, человек становится культурным: 1 когда научился вести себя в обществе и соблюдать приличия? 2 когда получается образование и профессию? 3 когда сам становится способным творить и развивать культуру, создовая культурный продукт?

Answer 1

Ответ 3 когда сам становится способным творить.....

Answer 2

When does a person become cultured?

The concept of becoming cultured is subjective and can vary depending on individual perspectives and cultural norms. However, there are several factors that are commonly associated with a person becoming cultured. Let's explore these factors:

1. Social Behavior and Etiquette: One perspective is that a person becomes cultured when they have learned how to conduct themselves in society and adhere to social norms and etiquette. This includes having good manners, showing respect for others, and being aware of appropriate behavior in different social settings. Learning these social skills is often considered an important aspect of becoming cultured.

2. Education and Profession: Another viewpoint is that a person becomes cultured when they have acquired a certain level of education and have established a profession. Education provides individuals with knowledge, critical thinking skills, and exposure to various subjects, which can contribute to their cultural development. Additionally, having a profession can indicate a level of expertise and specialization in a particular field, which is often associated with being cultured.

3. Creativity and Cultural Contribution: A third perspective is that a person becomes cultured when they are capable of creating and contributing to culture by producing cultural products. This can include creating art, literature, music, or other forms of creative expression. Being able to contribute to the cultural landscape demonstrates a deeper understanding and appreciation of culture, and is often seen as a hallmark of being cultured.

It's important to note that these perspectives are not mutually exclusive, and different individuals and cultures may prioritize different aspects of becoming cultured. Ultimately, becoming cultured is a lifelong process that involves continuous learning, personal growth, and engagement with various aspects of culture.