Question

Медицинская сестра Шутова не имея на это рраво выписала рецепт на получение наркотических средств на имя своего знакомого Иванова который страдал раком легкого и нуждаося в их приминений испытывая сильные боли . Установлено что для этого Шутова воспользовалась печатью врача онкологической клиники Пахомовой и ввела в заблуждение главного врача Аверьянову . Свои действия Шурова объяснила тем что хотела облегчить страдания Иванова Подлежит ли Шурова уголовной отвественности ????

Answer 1

Да, так как  она не имела права выписывать ему нар. средства и допускается версия, что она могла брать за это деньги, а это уже можно приравнять к наркоторговле

Answer 2

Medical Nurse Shuova's Actions and Criminal Responsibility

The actions of medical nurse Shuova, who prescribed narcotics to her acquaintance Ivanov under the name of another patient suffering from lung cancer, raise questions about her criminal responsibility. Shuova used the stamp of the oncology clinic's doctor, Pahomova, and deceived the chief physician, Averianov, about her actions. Shuova justified her actions by claiming that she wanted to alleviate Ivanov's suffering.

To determine whether Shuova is subject to criminal responsibility, it is necessary to consider the relevant laws and regulations governing the prescription and distribution of narcotics, as well as the potential legal consequences for her actions.

Prescription of Narcotics and Legal Framework

In many jurisdictions, the prescription and distribution of narcotics are strictly regulated due to their potential for abuse and harm. Medical professionals, such as doctors and nurses, are typically required to follow specific protocols and guidelines when prescribing narcotics to patients. These protocols often include verifying the patient's identity, medical condition, and the necessity of the prescribed medication.

Prescribing narcotics under false pretenses or using another person's name without proper authorization is generally considered a serious offense and may be subject to criminal penalties. However, the specific legal consequences can vary depending on the jurisdiction and the circumstances of the case.

Criminal Responsibility for Shuova's Actions

Based on the information provided, Shuova's actions appear to involve several potential legal violations. These include:

1. Forgery: Shuova used the stamp of the oncology clinic's doctor, Pahomova, without proper authorization. This act can be considered forgery, which is a criminal offense in many jurisdictions.

2. Deception: Shuova deceived the chief physician, Averianov, by prescribing narcotics under false pretenses. Deception or fraud in the medical field can also be subject to criminal charges.

3. Illegal Prescription: Shuova prescribed narcotics to Ivanov under the name of another patient, which is likely a violation of the regulations governing the prescription and distribution of narcotics.

The determination of Shuova's criminal responsibility would ultimately depend on the specific laws and regulations of the jurisdiction where the incident occurred. It would be necessary to consult the relevant legal provisions and consider the specific circumstances of the case, including any mitigating factors or extenuating circumstances.

Conclusion

In summary, the actions of medical nurse Shuova, who prescribed narcotics to her acquaintance Ivanov under false pretenses, raise concerns about her potential criminal responsibility. The specific legal consequences would depend on the jurisdiction and the applicable laws and regulations. It is advisable to consult legal professionals or authorities to obtain accurate and up-to-date information regarding the potential criminal liability in this case.