Question

Тема:(Міф про Нарциса) Як ви вважаєте, в чому полягає трагедія Нарциса? За що його було покарано? Чи є це покарання справедливим? Даю 30 балов

Answer 1

Відповідь:

Нарцис є персонажем французької трагедії Британніка, написаної Расіном в 1669 році, це драма про вбивство Бретаніка Нероном

За те, що він заперечував свою провину, його покарали дужче.

Кримінально-правовий зміст принципу справедливості полягає в тому, що покарання чи інша міра кримінально-правового впливу, застосована до особи, яка вчинила злочин, повинні бути справедливими, тобто відповідати тяжкості злочину, конкретним обставинам вчинення злочину і особливостям особистості злочинця.

Answer 2

The Tragedy of Narcissus

The myth of Narcissus is a well-known story from Greek mythology that explores themes of self-love, vanity, and punishment. According to the myth, Narcissus was a young and exceptionally beautiful hunter who was known for his arrogance and disdain towards others. He was the son of the river god Cephissus and the nymph Liriope.

The Tragedy of Narcissus: The tragedy of Narcissus lies in his excessive self-love and obsession with his own reflection. He was so captivated by his own beauty that he became infatuated with his own image, constantly gazing at himself in a pool of water. This self-obsession prevented him from forming meaningful connections with others and led to his ultimate downfall.

Punishment of Narcissus: As a punishment for his vanity and self-absorption, the gods decided to teach Narcissus a lesson. They caused him to fall deeply in love with his own reflection, which he believed to be a beautiful nymph. However, every time he tried to embrace or kiss his reflection, it would disappear, leaving him heartbroken and longing for the unattainable.

Is the Punishment Justified? The question of whether the punishment inflicted upon Narcissus is justified is subjective and open to interpretation. On one hand, Narcissus' excessive self-love and disregard for others could be seen as deserving of punishment. His vanity and arrogance prevented him from experiencing genuine love and connection with others, leading to his isolation and eventual demise.

On the other hand, some may argue that the punishment was too severe for Narcissus' actions. While his self-obsession was harmful, it could be seen as a result of his own insecurities and lack of self-esteem. In this view, the punishment may be seen as excessive and disproportionate to his actions.

It is important to note that myths often serve as cautionary tales and moral lessons. The story of Narcissus warns against the dangers of excessive self-love and the importance of finding a balance between self-acceptance and consideration for others.

Overall, whether the punishment is considered just or not depends on individual perspectives and interpretations of the myth.