Question

Чем опера барокко отличается от рок оперы?

Answer 1

Ответ:

Во-первых, отличие пролегает через само историческое происхождение того и другого жанра. Жанр оперы зародился в эпоху Нового времени, в XVI-XVII вв., в крупнейших странах Западной Европы, таких как Англия, Франция и Германия. Рок-опера - продукт исключительно ХХ века и американской массовой культуры. Во-вторых, опера может опираться на какой-либо литературный первоисточник, тогда как для рок-оперы пишется оригинальный текст. В-третьих, количественный признак: число написанных к настоящему времени опер достаточно велико и насчитывает не одну сотню, тогда как рок-опер лишь несколько десятков. В-четвертых, степенью популярности. Опера всегда считалась жанром для избранных, для элиты, для людей, хорошо разбирающихся в музыкальном искусстве и могущим его адекватно оценить. Рок - музыка более демократичная, понятная самым широким слоям. Наконец, в-пятых, сама стилистика оперы более спокойная и выдержанная, нежели в рок-опере с ее бурными всплесками эмоций.

Answer 2

Difference between Baroque Opera and Rock Opera

Baroque opera and rock opera are two distinct genres of music that emerged in different time periods and have different characteristics. Here are some key differences between the two:

1. Time Period: - Baroque opera originated in the 17th and early 18th centuries, while rock opera emerged in the 20th century.

2. Musical Style: - Baroque opera is characterized by its ornate and elaborate musical style, with intricate melodies, complex harmonies, and elaborate vocal ornamentation. - Rock opera, on the other hand, is rooted in rock music, featuring amplified instruments, strong rhythms, and a more contemporary sound.

3. Subject Matter: - Baroque opera often drew inspiration from mythology, ancient history, or biblical stories. It focused on themes of love, tragedy, and morality. - Rock opera typically tells a narrative story, often with a concept or theme running through the entire work. The subject matter can vary widely, ranging from personal stories to social and political commentary.

4. Performance Style: - Baroque opera was performed in grand opera houses with elaborate sets, costumes, and stage machinery. It involved trained singers performing in a formal and stylized manner. - Rock opera is often performed in concert settings or smaller theaters, with a focus on the music and the energy of the performers. It may incorporate elements of rock concerts, such as lighting effects and audience interaction.

5. Instruments: - Baroque opera primarily used orchestral instruments of the time, such as harpsichords, violins, and woodwinds. - Rock opera relies heavily on electric guitars, bass guitars, drums, and keyboards, along with other amplified instruments commonly used in rock music.

It's important to note that these are general differences between the two genres, and there may be variations within each genre. Additionally, individual works within each genre may exhibit unique characteristics that deviate from the typical conventions.