Question

Измена Наташи князю Андрею. Как вы оцениваете поступок Наташи? Как Соня и Ахросимова реагируют на поступок Наташи? Могла ли Вера так поступить?

Answer 1

 Наташа долгое время была легкомысленной ,и неудивительно ,что Анатоль смог вскружить ей так быстро голову.
Когда князь Андрей ушел на войну,любовь Наташи к Болконскому должна была пройти тяжелое испытание ,испытание на верность.Она и подумать не могла какой долгой будет их разлука с князем.Изо дня в день она становилась все грустнее,и все реже слышался ее веселый голосок.В один из таких дней,Наташа подошла к матери и разрыдалась:"Мне нужен он!"
А теперь ,представте,что с ней случилось,когда она встретила Анатоля,слывшего ужасным сердцеедом.Она просто не смогла устоять перед его красотой и обаянием.

Соня и Марья Дмитриевна Ахросимова  всеми способами пытались скрыть весть о том, что Наташа пыталась сбежать с Анатолем.Можно сказать .что они обе спасли Наташу от всеобщего позора.

Вера врятли бы так сделала.В ней не было той страсти и жажды приключений , какими  славилась Наташа.Но не могу сказать,что эта черта характера делала Веру лучше.

Answer 2

Natasha's Betrayal of Prince Andrei and Evaluation of Her Actions

Natasha's betrayal of Prince Andrei in Leo Tolstoy's novel "War and Peace" is a significant event in the story. Her actions have different implications and are viewed differently by various characters in the novel.

Natasha's actions can be seen as a betrayal because she breaks her engagement with Prince Andrei and instead falls in love with and marries Anatole Kuragin. This decision goes against the expectations and wishes of her family, especially her cousin Sonya and her friend Princess Marya. It also goes against the moral and social norms of the time.

Evaluation of Natasha's Actions: Natasha's actions can be evaluated in different ways, depending on one's perspective. Some may view her actions as impulsive and selfish, as she prioritizes her own desires and emotions over her commitment to Prince Andrei. Others may see her actions as a result of her youth and naivety, as she is easily swayed by Anatole's charm and attention.

It is important to note that Natasha's actions are not without consequences. Her decision to betray Prince Andrei leads to a series of events that have a profound impact on her life and the lives of those around her. It causes significant emotional pain and turmoil for Prince Andrei, who is deeply hurt by her betrayal.

Sonya and Akhrosimova's Reactions to Natasha's Actions

Sonya, Natasha's cousin, is deeply affected by Natasha's betrayal of Prince Andrei. Sonya has been in love with Prince Andrei for a long time and had hoped to marry him. Natasha's actions not only shatter Sonya's dreams but also strain their relationship. Sonya is devastated by the loss of Prince Andrei and feels betrayed by Natasha, whom she considers to be like a sister.

Akhrosimova, Natasha's godmother, is also disappointed and disapproving of Natasha's actions. She had hoped that Natasha would make a suitable match with Prince Andrei and secure her future. Akhrosimova sees Natasha's decision to marry Anatole as reckless and impulsive, and she believes that Natasha has made a grave mistake.

Vera's Potential Actions

Vera, Natasha's older sister, is portrayed as a more reserved and practical character in the novel. It is unlikely that Vera would have made the same choices as Natasha. Vera is depicted as being more cautious and level-headed, and she prioritizes stability and social expectations. Therefore, it is unlikely that Vera would have betrayed Prince Andrei in the same way that Natasha did.

However, it is important to remember that characters in a novel are complex and can surprise readers with their actions. While it is unlikely that Vera would have made the same choices as Natasha, it is not impossible. The novel explores the complexities of human nature and the unpredictability of human behavior, so it is always possible for characters to act in unexpected ways.

In conclusion, Natasha's betrayal of Prince Andrei in "War and Peace" is a significant event in the novel. Her actions are viewed differently by different characters, with Sonya and Akhrosimova expressing disappointment and disapproval. While Natasha's actions can be seen as a betrayal, they can also be evaluated as the result of her youth and naivety. It is unlikely that Vera, Natasha's sister, would have made the same choices, given her more practical and reserved nature. However, characters in the novel are complex, and their actions can sometimes surprise readers.