Question

Сравните произведения выше высказывания критиков Антоновича ,Писарева страхова о базарове с кем из них вы согласны и с кем нет?почему роман отцы и дети

Answer 1

Сравнение - это всего лишь равенство на что-либо!

Answer 2

Comparing Criticisms of Bazarov by Antonovich, Pisarev, and Strakhov

The criticisms of Bazarov by Antonovich, Pisarev, and Strakhov provide different perspectives on the character and significance of Bazarov in the novel "Fathers and Sons" by Ivan Turgenev. Let's compare the viewpoints of these critics and analyze their stances on Bazarov.

Antonovich's View: Antonovich, a critic from the late 19th to early 20th century, presents a critical view of Bazarov. He emphasizes the negative impact of Bazarov's nihilistic beliefs and behavior. Antonovich portrays Bazarov as a disruptive force, challenging traditional values and causing turmoil in the society of the novel.

Pisarev's View: Pisarev, another critic from the same era, also offers a critical perspective on Bazarov. His criticism likely focuses on Bazarov's nihilistic philosophy and its implications for society. Pisarev's viewpoint may align with Antonovich's in highlighting the disruptive nature of Bazarov's beliefs and actions.

Strakhov's View: Strakhov, a contemporary of Antonovich and Pisarev, provides a contrasting view of Bazarov. His perspective may differ from the other critics, possibly emphasizing the positive or redeeming qualities of Bazarov, or offering a more nuanced interpretation of his character and impact on the novel.

Personal Agreement and Disagreement:

In considering these criticisms, it's important to note that each critic's viewpoint reflects the intellectual and cultural context of their time. Personally, I find merit in both Antonovich's and Pisarev's criticisms, as they highlight the disruptive and potentially destructive aspects of Bazarov's nihilism. However, I also recognize the potential for Strakhov's perspective to offer a more balanced and nuanced understanding of Bazarov's character and role in the novel.

Significance of "Fathers and Sons":

The novel "Fathers and Sons" by Ivan Turgenev is a significant work in Russian literature, exploring generational conflicts, ideological clashes, and the impact of social change. Bazarov, as a central character, embodies the tensions between traditional values and emerging nihilistic philosophies, making the novel a rich source for critical analysis and interpretation.

In conclusion, the criticisms of Bazarov by Antonovich, Pisarev, and Strakhov offer diverse perspectives on the character and significance of Bazarov in "Fathers and Sons." While I find merit in the critical views of Antonovich and Pisarev, I also acknowledge the potential value of Strakhov's perspective in providing a more nuanced understanding of Bazarov's role in the novel.