Question

В произведении "Собачье сердце" Почему только физического облика человека недостаточно для собаки, чтобы она стала достойным членом общества? Помогите пожалуйста!!!

Answer 1

Ответ:

вот

Объяснение:

у собак инстинкты у людей разум.

Здоровый человек прекрасно понимает что делает и как поступает,даже если итог действий не лучший. Собак воспитывают для того что бы они нравились вам и другим людям, никто не хочет оказаться в одной комнате с животным которое может сделать вам больно,а если сделает то вы его убьёте.Все в этом мире несёт в себе темную сторону, но только те кто ее не скрывают оказываются ужасными тварями.

Если человек поступит плохо то другие люди осудят его,а только потом забудут , потому что им все равно.Все мы такие же. Всем на будет все равно , пока мы не окажемся в шкуре жертвы.

Answer 2

The Significance of Physical Appearance in "Heart of a Dog"

In the novel "Heart of a Dog" by Mikhail Bulgakov, the theme of physical appearance is explored in relation to a dog's ability to become a worthy member of society. The story revolves around the transformation of a stray dog named Sharik into a human-like creature through a scientific experiment. While Sharik's physical appearance changes, it becomes clear that physical transformation alone is not enough for him to be considered a valuable member of society.

1. The Importance of Physical Appearance for a Dog

Dogs are often valued for their physical attributes, such as their breed, size, and appearance. These characteristics can influence how they are perceived and treated by humans. In the novel, Sharik's transformation into a human-like creature initially sparks curiosity and interest among the people around him. However, it becomes evident that physical appearance alone does not determine one's worth or ability to contribute to society.

2. The Limitations of Physical Transformation

While Sharik's physical appearance changes, his behavior and mindset remain largely unchanged. He continues to exhibit dog-like instincts and lacks the intellectual and emotional capacity of a human. This highlights the limitations of physical transformation in determining one's worth as a member of society. Merely altering one's appearance does not automatically confer the qualities and abilities necessary for active participation in human society.

3. The Importance of Intellectual and Emotional Development

To be considered a valuable member of society, individuals need more than just a physical presence. Intellectual and emotional development, as well as the ability to understand and adhere to societal norms and values, are crucial. In the case of Sharik, his lack of intellectual and emotional growth hinders his integration into human society, despite his altered physical appearance.

4. The Role of Socialization and Education

The novel emphasizes the importance of socialization and education in shaping an individual's behavior and mindset. Sharik's transformation highlights the need for proper upbringing and education to develop the skills and qualities necessary for active participation in society. Without these elements, physical transformation alone is insufficient for someone to become a worthy member of society.

In conclusion, "Heart of a Dog" explores the idea that physical appearance alone is not enough for a dog to become a valuable member of society. The novel highlights the importance of intellectual and emotional development, as well as socialization and education, in determining one's worth and ability to contribute to society. Physical transformation may spark curiosity, but it is the inner qualities and abilities that truly define one's place in the community.