Question

В чем заключается исторический выбор Александра Невского в пользу подчинения русских земель Золотой Орде; (почему подчинился)

Answer 1

Добровольно обратился к ордынцам за ярлыком на княжение, исправно платил дань, в отличие от своих переемников.

Answer 2

Historical Choice of Alexander Nevsky in Favor of Subjugating Russian Lands to the Golden Horde

The historical choice of Alexander Nevsky to submit Russian lands to the Golden Horde was influenced by several factors.

1. Political Realities: - Alexander Nevsky's decision to submit to the Golden Horde was influenced by the political realities of the time. The Mongol invasion had already devastated many Russian cities, and the Golden Horde held significant power over the region.

2. Pragmatic Diplomacy: - Alexander Nevsky's submission to the Golden Horde can be seen as a pragmatic diplomatic move to ensure the survival of the Russian principalities. By submitting to the Mongol rule, he aimed to protect his people from further devastation and maintain a degree of autonomy within the Mongol system.

3. Protection of Russian Lands: - Submitting to the Golden Horde was also a way to protect Russian lands from further destruction and secure some level of stability under the Mongol rule.

4. Long-Term Vision: - Alexander Nevsky's decision may have been driven by a long-term vision of preserving the Russian state and its people, even if it meant temporary subjugation to the Mongol rule.

5. Economic Considerations: - Economic factors may have also played a role in Alexander Nevsky's decision, as submitting to the Golden Horde could have provided some economic benefits and stability for the Russian lands.

In summary, Alexander Nevsky's historical choice to submit Russian lands to the Golden Horde was a complex decision influenced by political, diplomatic, and pragmatic considerations aimed at protecting the Russian principalities and ensuring their survival in the face of the Mongol invasion and rule.