Question

В чем заключалась противоречивость России в отношении греческого восстания? _____________ Можно ли конкретный ответ? Большинство ответов - это непонятные выписки из интернета. Заранее спасибо! Всегда вручаете в тупиковых ситуациях:)

Answer 1

Россия хотела создать православный свободный от османов Балканский полуостров, но никаких действий в этой войне не принимала.

Answer 2

The Contradictions in Russia's Attitude towards the Greek Revolution

The Russian attitude towards the Greek Revolution of 1821 was indeed contradictory. On one hand, Russia expressed support for the Greek cause and saw it as an opportunity to weaken the Ottoman Empire, which was seen as a common enemy. On the other hand, Russia was cautious about openly supporting the revolution due to several factors.

1. Geopolitical Considerations: Russia was concerned about the potential consequences of openly supporting the Greek Revolution. The Ottoman Empire was a major power in the region, and Russia did not want to risk a direct confrontation with the Ottomans. Additionally, Russia had its own territorial ambitions in the region, particularly in the Balkans, and did not want to provoke other European powers by openly supporting Greek independence.

2. Balance of Power in Europe: Russia was also mindful of the balance of power in Europe. The European powers, including Russia, were wary of any major disruptions to the existing order. They were concerned that supporting the Greek Revolution could lead to a wider conflict or encourage other nationalist movements across Europe. Therefore, Russia sought to maintain a delicate balance between supporting the Greek cause and avoiding a direct confrontation with the Ottomans.

3. Internal Political Considerations: Internally, Russia had its own challenges to deal with. Tsar Alexander I, who initially expressed sympathy for the Greek cause, faced opposition from conservative elements within the Russian government and society. These conservatives were concerned about the potential implications of supporting a revolution that could inspire similar movements within Russia. As a result, Alexander I had to navigate these internal political dynamics and strike a balance between supporting the Greek Revolution and maintaining stability within Russia.

4. Orthodox Christianity: Another factor that influenced Russia's attitude towards the Greek Revolution was the shared religious identity between the Greeks and the Russians. Both nations were predominantly Orthodox Christian, and this created a sense of solidarity and sympathy towards the Greek cause. However, Russia had to carefully balance its religious affinity with the geopolitical and political considerations mentioned earlier.

In summary, the contradictions in Russia's attitude towards the Greek Revolution can be attributed to a combination of geopolitical considerations, the balance of power in Europe, internal political dynamics, and the shared religious identity between the Greeks and the Russians. Russia expressed support for the Greek cause but was cautious about openly supporting the revolution due to the potential risks and consequences involved.

[[1]]