Question

Почему отмена крепостного права привела поначалу не к развитию, а к развалу промышленности?

Answer 1

Потому что сначала люди стали вольными и не работали на своих бывших хозяев, а на то что бы создать своё занятие нужно было время.

Answer 2

The Abolition of Serfdom and its Impact on Industrialization

The abolition of serfdom in Russia in 1861 was a significant event in the country's history. While the emancipation of the serfs was a step towards social progress and the end of feudalism, it initially had negative consequences for industrialization. Here's a detailed explanation of why the abolition of serfdom led to the decline of the Russian industrial sector:

1. Economic Impact: - The emancipation of the serfs resulted in the redistribution of land. The former serfs were granted small plots of land, which were often insufficient for agricultural production on a large scale. As a result, agricultural productivity decreased, leading to a decline in food production and an increase in food prices. - The redistribution of land also fragmented agricultural production, making it difficult to implement modern farming techniques and technologies. This further hindered agricultural productivity and limited the surplus available for investment in industrial development.

2. Labor Shortages: - The abolition of serfdom led to a shortage of labor in the agricultural sector. Many former serfs migrated to urban areas in search of better opportunities, leaving a significant gap in the agricultural workforce. This labor shortage affected agricultural productivity and reduced the availability of food for both domestic consumption and industrial workers. - The shortage of agricultural labor also had a negative impact on the supply of raw materials for the industrial sector. Industries such as textiles, which relied heavily on raw materials from agriculture, faced difficulties in sourcing the necessary inputs for production.

3. Lack of Capital and Investment: - The emancipation of the serfs resulted in the payment of compensation to the landowners for the loss of their serfs. This compensation was financed through state loans, which created a significant burden on the Russian economy. The funds that could have been used for industrial development were diverted towards debt repayment, limiting the availability of capital for investment in the industrial sector. - The lack of capital and investment hindered the modernization and expansion of industries. Without sufficient funds, industries struggled to adopt new technologies, improve infrastructure, and increase production capacity.

4. Political and Social Factors: - The abolition of serfdom was accompanied by political and social instability. The transition from a feudal system to a more modern society was challenging and often met with resistance from the nobility and landowners. This resistance hindered the implementation of reforms necessary for industrial development. - The social and economic disparities that persisted after the abolition of serfdom also contributed to social unrest and political instability. These factors further undermined the stability needed for sustained industrial growth.

In conclusion, the abolition of serfdom in Russia initially led to a decline in industrial development. Economic factors such as decreased agricultural productivity, labor shortages, and a lack of capital and investment, along with political and social instability, all played a role in hindering the growth of the industrial sector. It took time for the Russian economy to recover from these challenges and for industrialization to gain momentum.

Note: The information provided above is based on search result snippets. For more in-depth analysis and a comprehensive understanding of the topic, it is recommended to refer to the full articles from the sources cited.