Question

СРОЧНО 30 БАЛОВ! ответить на вопрос: Если бы вы были русским князем, вы бы подчинялись или сопротивлялись ордынской власти?

Answer 1

Сопротивлялись.

Ордынская власть отбросила русские земли назад в развитии. Ордынские властители не содействовали централизации на Руси, объединению её земель, а препятствовала этому. В из интересах было разжигать вражду между русскими князьями, не допуская их единства. Всё, что происходило в те годы, в плане развития Руси, делалось против воли русских людей.

Answer 2

If I were a Russian prince, would I submit to or resist the Mongol rule?

As a Russian prince, the decision to submit to or resist the Mongol rule would depend on various factors, including the specific historical context and the balance of power at the time. It is important to note that the Mongol rule in Russia, known as the Golden Horde, lasted for several centuries, from the 13th to the 15th century. During this period, the Mongols exerted significant control over the Russian principalities, collecting tribute and imposing their authority.

Historical Context: The Mongol invasion of Russia began in the early 13th century when the Mongol Empire, led by Genghis Khan and later his successors, launched a series of military campaigns. The Mongols quickly conquered many Russian principalities, establishing their rule over the region. The Mongol rule had a profound impact on Russian society, politics, and culture.

Factors Influencing Submission or Resistance: 1. Military Power: The Mongols were known for their military might and effective tactics. Russian princes would have considered the military strength of the Mongols before deciding whether to submit or resist. The Mongols' ability to swiftly conquer and control vast territories would have made resistance a challenging prospect. 2. Economic Considerations: The Mongols imposed a system of tribute and taxation on the Russian principalities. Some Russian princes may have chosen to submit to the Mongols to avoid further destruction and economic hardship. Others may have resisted to protect their own wealth and resources. 3. Political Realities: The Mongols established a hierarchical system of governance, allowing Russian princes to retain some autonomy as long as they paid tribute and acknowledged Mongol authority. Some princes may have seen submission as a way to maintain their own power and influence within this system. 4. Geopolitical Factors: The Mongol Empire was vast, and resistance against such a powerful force would have required significant alliances and resources. Russian princes may have considered the geopolitical landscape and the potential consequences of resisting the Mongols.

Conclusion: In summary, the decision to submit to or resist the Mongol rule as a Russian prince would have depended on a complex interplay of military power, economic considerations, political realities, and geopolitical factors. Some princes may have chosen to submit to the Mongols to avoid further destruction and maintain their own power within the Mongol system, while others may have resisted to protect their wealth and resources. Ultimately, the specific circumstances and individual motivations of each prince would have influenced their decision.

Please note that the information provided is based on historical context and general knowledge. For more specific details and insights, further research into the specific time period and Russian principalities would be necessary.